Evaluation of SPT-Based Liquefaction Assessment Methods in China

Yi-Fan Zhang,Rui Wang,Jian-Min Zhang,Jian-Hong Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-0131-5_38

2018-01-01

Abstract:Various SPT-based empirical methods for liquefaction assessment have been developed over the past decades. However, the effectiveness of these methods for liquefaction assessment in China needs further investigation. This paper evaluates the efficacy of currently commonly used SPT-based methods for liquefaction assessment in China based on existing earthquake liquefaction data. Through calculating and analyzing the prediction success rate (PSR) of in-site liquefied and non-liquefied sites, the applicability of several major SPT-based methods for liquefaction assessment in China is discussed. The analysis results show that the JRA method is in general over-conservative for application in China and is more applicable to liquefaction sites with large sand depth and deep groundwater table; meanwhile the NCEER, I-B and T-Y methods tend to underestimate liquefaction potential in China, and are relatively effective for sites with great acceleration or large magnitude; furthermore, the CSDB methods have a relatively high success rate of liquefaction judgement based on data from historic earthquake data before the 1990's, but a lower success rate for the two most recent earthquakes, especially in the 2003 Bachu earthquake. Based on these findings, further expansion of China's existing liquefied database for liquefaction assessment is suggested to improve the CSDB methods, and the JRA, NCEER, I-B and T-Y methods also require further improvement based on China's liquefaction data when applied to China.