Reflecting The Theory Of Hinge Propositions Of On Certainty Criticizing Religious Skepticism

Cao Jianbo
2014-01-01
International Journal of Sino-Western Studies
Abstract:Hinge propositions are undoubtable, because (1) Infallible hinge propositions are logical or grammatical propositions, (2) There are no reasonable reasons to doubt the propositions, (3) The propositions are the basis for actions, for thoughts, for doubt, (4) To doubt the propositions is a sign of madness or rhetoric. Taking "God exists" as a hinge proposition, the anti-skeptics put forward two strategies to refute religious skepticism. The essence of using the theory of hinge proposition to criticize religious skepticism is that of using externalism to criticize internalism. Their theoretical commitments are different, so the criticism is unsuccessful. Under the premise of the internalist commitment of epistemology, the defenders of religious beliefs should re-examine the existing methods and pursue other way.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?