A Comparison Of Three Anti-Corruption Mechanisms: An Experimental Study

Xinchao Zhang,Lu Liu,Liangcong Fan
2014-01-01
Abstract:This paper examines the efficiency of three anti-corruption mechanisms based on Public Goods Game with a manager, who can decide to embezzle the contributions or not. The mechanisms are intrinsic incentive anti-corruption mechanism (information disclosing), extrinsic incentive anti-corruption mechanism (conventional top-down auditing), and a mechanism combined the intrinsic and intrinsic extrinsic incentive (giving agents thepossibility to report embezzler, knowing that reports lead to top-down auditing with some low probability), respectively. The results suggest that the contributions to the public accounts significantly decrease when there is a risk of embezzlement by managers; and extrinsic incentive anti-corruption mechanism is more effective in curbing embezzlement both in terms of the amount and the frequency; in contrast, the intrinsic incentive anti-corruption mechanism only decreases the amount. However, the combined mechanism is ineffective.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?