Equity Incentives granted to Supervisor,Collision Orientation and Corporate Governance Restriction——Empirical Research Based on Listed Companies' Panel Data in China
XU Ning,XU Xiang-yi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2012.01.007
2012-01-01
Abstract:Taking the opportunity of the split share reform,Chinese listed companies began to explore and develop equity-based incentives.On the condition that the institution environment is not mature enough,the reasonable selection and distribution of incentive objects are the keys to realize and maximize the incentive effect.To ensure supervisors' independence,China Securities Regulatory Commission(CSRC) announced that equity incentives granted to supervisors are forbidden.The relative policies not only induce the suspension of many listed companies' equity incentive plan,but also make many superiors resign and rotate.The theoretical problem behind this system transformation attracts the attention of many researchers at home and aboard.Do equity-based incentives granted to supervisors have a positive or negative effect on governance efficiency? So the rationality of supervisor equity incentives becomes the points at issue.The main objective of our paper is to find theoretical and empirical evidences for the above issue to be solved urgently. In the one-tier corporate governance system just as American,the potential effects of the equity incentives granted to the independent directors /or audit committee members have been the subject of many studies.The collision risks caused by the equity incentives granted to the audit committee members are mainly displayed in the recent financial crisis.Archambeault et al.(2008) and Cullinan et al.(2010) find an association between audit committee incentive-based compensation and financial reporting failures reported in restatements.A plausible explanation for the findings reported in the above studies is that granting options to directors aligns directors' financial interests more closely with management,management,who also typically have large numbers of stock options(Persellin,2009).Chinese listed companies adopt a two-tier board structure,a Board of Directors and a Supervisory Board.According to the special characteristics of supervisors,researchers began to explore the incentive mechanisms granted to them.The positive effects of compensating supervisors with stock options or other equity incentive models have been approved by many researchers.And the corporate governance appraisal systems developed by Research Center of Corporate Governance of Nankai University have adopted superiors' stock ownership as the factors of superiors' competency.However,some researchers also find that granting equity incentives to supervisors may not improve their supervising motivation and competency,or even cause collision risk. Based on the perspective of corporate governance integration theory,we adopt the balanced Panel Data from 2006～2009 of Chinese listed companies to do the empirical research.The results show that the dual collision orientations that could be induced by the equity incentives granted to supervisors aren't obvious.On the contrary,they have a positive effect on the dual agency problems under the effects of the moderators such as independent directors' supervision,equity restriction and debt restriction.Concretely speaking,there is a negative relationship between supervisors' stock ownership and the first agency cost under the moderate effects of independent directors' supervision and debt restriction,that is,the collision orientation between supervisors and agents has been controlled.And under the moderate effects of equity restriction,supervisors' stock ownership also has a negative effect on the second agency cost,that is,the collision orientation between supervisors and principals has been controlled.Therefore,we point out that only forbidding the equity incentives granted to supervisors is not the best measures.Improving corporate governance restricted level is the prerequisite to achieve the effect of equity incentives granted to supervisors and to avoid the dual collision risks effectively.