Rethinking Chemistry for a Circular Economy

Klaus Kuemmerer,James H. Clark,Vania G. Zuin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aba4979

IF: 56.9

2020-01-01

Science

Abstract:Chemical complexity complicates product recycling and manufacturing sustainability

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Circular economy design considerations for research and process development in the chemical sciences

James H. Clark,Thomas J. Farmer,Lorenzo Herrero-Davila,James Sherwood

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/c6gc00501b

IF: 9.8

2016-01-01

Green Chemistry

Abstract:A circular economy will look to chemistry to provide the basis of innovative products, made from renewable feedstocks and designed to be reused, recycled, or the feedstock renewed through natural processes. The substances that products are made of will increasingly be treated as a resource equal to the raw materials, and not just disposed of. This perspective discusses the role of chemists in a world without waste.
Circular Economy and Green Chemistry: The Need for Radical Innovative Approaches in the Design for New Products

Amos Ncube,Sandile Mtetwa,Mahak Bukhari,Gabriella Fiorentino,Renato Passaro

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/en16041752

IF: 3.2

2023-02-10

Energies

Abstract:The idea of a circular economy (CE) has gained ground over the past ten years as a means of addressing sustainable development and getting around the limitations of the current and linear dominant production and consumption patterns. The primary goal of a CE is to encourage the adoption of closing-the-loop production methods to improve resource use efficiency, modify chemical processes, and increase product and material lifespan. According to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, which focuses on 17 Sustainable Development Goals, 14 of which call for the appropriate application of green chemistry (GC) concepts and patterns, the role that chemistry may play in the shift toward more sustainable models is critical. By serving as the foundation for novel products made from renewable feedstocks and designed to be reused, recycled, or recovered with the associated minimum energy requirements, green and sustainable chemistry could be the key to unlocking the economic potential of the CE toward new product design and ultimately solving waste management problems. The aim of this perspective paper, while using a variety of literature sources, is to essentially capture the main issues associated with the CE and GC paradigms and how these two approaches can merge toward sustainable business models and the production of new materials. This integration focuses on reducing waste, conserving resources, and minimizing negative environmental impacts, while also considering economic viability. However, the obstacles to achieving implementation of the CE and GC principles are investment, environmental education, and legislation. To advance toward the circular economy and green chemistry, international agreements should be reconsidered to provide an appropriate framework, including the creation of incentives for businesses and individuals to adopt circular practices, the establishment of education programs to promote the benefits of circular practices, and the development of regulations to support the transition to sustainable production and consumption patterns.

energy & fuels
Designing for a green chemistry future

Walter Leitner,Julie B. Zimmerman,Paul T. Anastas,Hanno C. Erythropel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.aay3060

IF: 56.9

2020-01-24

Science

Abstract:The material basis of a sustainable society will depend on chemical products and processes that are designed following principles that make them conducive to life. Important inherent properties of molecules need to be considered from the earliest stage—the design stage—to address whether compounds and processes are depleting versus renewable, toxic versus benign, and persistent versus readily degradable. Products, feedstocks, and manufacturing processes will need to integrate the principles of green chemistry and green engineering under an expanded definition of performance that includes sustainability considerations. This transformation will require the best of the traditions of science and innovation coupled with new emerging systems thinking and systems design that begins at the molecular level and results in a positive impact on the global scale.

multidisciplinary sciences
Beyond Reductionist Thinking in Chemistry for Sustainability

Paul T. Anastas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trechm.2019.03.007

IF: 22.448

2019-05-01

Trends in Chemistry

Abstract:Great breakthroughs in chemistry over the past two centuries have been accomplished largely through reductionist methods. However, the incredible sustainability challenges that we face as a civilization are systems challenges, requiring careful combination of knowledge gained from reductionist approaches with integrative-systems thinking to inform designs for a sustainable future.

chemistry, multidisciplinary
Catalysis for Carbon‐Circularity: Emerging Concepts and Role of Inorganic Chemistry

Gabriele Centi,Yuefeng Liu,Siglinda Perathoner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cssc.202400843

IF: 8.4

2024-05-30

ChemSusChem

Abstract:Carbon circularity is crucial for achieving a circular economy but has wider implications and impacts with respect to the circularity of materials. It has an in‐depth transformative effect on the economy. CO2 recycling is a critical component for this objective, with catalysis and inorganic chemistry playing a determining role in achieving this challenge. This concept paper presents some examples, as food for thought, of unconventional aspects in developing thermal and electro/photocatalysts for recycling CO2. The aspects discussed regard designing novel materials for CO2 thermo‐ or electro‐conversion and developing novel nanostructured electrodes.

chemistry, multidisciplinary,green & sustainable science & technology
Chemical Industry and Circular Economy

石磊,张天柱

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:0253-4320.2004.07.001

2004-01-01

Abstract:The chemical industry once played a great role in creating a "mass production,mass consumption" society,and will also play the same role in creating a recycling-oriented society.Followed by the introduction of circular economy conception and international experiences,this paper discusses the relationship between green chemistry and circular economy.Some fundamental suggestions are finally given for the development of the chemical industry according to circular economy principles.
Modern chemistry is rubbish

Hannah Flerlage,J. Chris Slootweg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41570-023-00523-9

IF: 34.5695

2023-08-01

Nature Reviews Chemistry

Abstract:To combat worsening environmental crises, chemistry needs a redesign. We see the need for a triple focus on efficiency, safety and circularity as a prerequisite for chemistry to serve sustainability and ensure that essential chemical products and processes are waste-free, functional and safe for both humans and the environment.

chemistry, multidisciplinary
Using Green Chemistry to Progress a Circular Fashion Industry

James H. Clark

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogsc.2022.100685

IF: 9.3

2022-01-01

Current Opinion in Green and Sustainable Chemistry

Abstract:The fashion industry is strongly connected to consumer affluence and with more and more people worldwide, the demand for new and ever more sophisticated clothes seems inexhaustible. This translates into the production and consumption of very large quantities of natural and synthetic materials, and treatment chemicals. The lack of an established recycling industry to deal with the resulting waste streams coupled with the increasing complexity of the products means that we are losing most of the consumed resources as wastes. The presence of so many chemicals in these wastes can exaggerate the problem. Here, we look at the scale of the problem but also of the opportunity for waste valorisation. Particular attention is given to the different types of recycling that are possible and including the conversion of these wastes into valuable chemicals. Some methods to improve apparel lifecycles upstream are also considered.
Circularity in polymers: addressing performance and sustainability challenges using dynamic covalent chemistries

Tianwei Yan,Alex H Balzer,Katie M Herbert,Thomas H Epps 3rd,LaShanda T J Korley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc00551h

2023-05-05

Abstract:The circularity of current and future polymeric materials is a major focus of fundamental and applied research, as undesirable end-of-life outcomes and waste accumulation are global problems that impact our society. The recycling or repurposing of thermoplastics and thermosets is an attractive solution to these issues, yet both options are encumbered by poor property retention upon reuse, along with heterogeneities in common waste streams that limit property optimization. Dynamic covalent chemistry, when applied to polymeric materials, enables the targeted design of reversible bonds that can be tailored to specific reprocessing conditions to help address conventional recycling challenges. In this review, we highlight the key features of several dynamic covalent chemistries that can promote closed-loop recyclability and we discuss recent synthetic progress towards incorporating these chemistries into new polymers and existing commodity plastics. Next, we outline how dynamic covalent bonds and polymer network structure influence thermomechanical properties related to application and recyclability, with a focus on predictive physical models that describe network rearrangement. Finally, we examine the potential economic and environmental impacts of dynamic covalent polymeric materials in closed-loop processing using elements derived from techno-economic analysis and life-cycle assessment, including minimum selling prices and greenhouse gas emissions. Throughout each section, we discuss interdisciplinary obstacles that hinder the widespread adoption of dynamic polymers and present opportunities and new directions toward the realization of circularity in polymeric materials.
Circularity in mixed-plastic chemical recycling enabled by variable rates of polydiketoenamine hydrolysis

Jeremy Demarteau,Alexander R. Epstein,Peter R. Christensen,Mark Abubekerov,Hai Wang,Simon J. Teat,Trevor J. Seguin,Christopher W. Chan,Corinne D. Scown,Thomas P. Russell,Jay D. Keasling,Kristin A. Persson,Brett A. Helms

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abp8823

IF: 13.6

2022-07-22

Science Advances

Abstract:Footwear, carpet, automotive interiors, and multilayer packaging are examples of products manufactured from several types of polymers whose inextricability poses substantial challenges for recycling at the end of life. Here, we show that chemical circularity in mixed-polymer recycling becomes possible by controlling the rates of depolymerization of polydiketoenamines (PDK) over several orders of magnitude through molecular engineering. Stepwise deconstruction of mixed-PDK composites, laminates, and assemblies is chemospecific, allowing a prescribed subset of monomers, fillers, and additives to be recovered under pristine condition at each stage of the recycling process. We provide a theoretical framework to understand PDK depolymerization via acid-catalyzed hydrolysis and experimentally validate trends predicted for the rate-limiting step. The control achieved by PDK resins in managing chemical and material entropy points to wide-ranging opportunities for pairing circular design with sustainable manufacturing.

multidisciplinary sciences
Contributions of heterogeneous catalysis enabling resource efficiency and circular economy

Sonja D Mürtz,Regina Palkovits

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsta.2023.0264

2024-11-09

Abstract:Our industry today is predominantly based on linear value chains. Raw materials are extracted from primary sources, processed into products, used, and disposed of at the end of their life cycle. This linear economy causes a wide range of negative environmental impacts owing to the resulting greenhouse gas emissions and pollution of marine and terrestrial ecosystems. Closed carbon cycles and climate-neutral energy production are essential for the production not only of fuels but also of all chemicals, including plastics and fertilizers, to counteract climate change and further damage to the environment. In this regard, this article discusses the importance of heterogeneous catalysts for selected technologies associated with this transformation of the resource base and energy supply. It discusses the technological framework conditions of a net CO2-neutral industry, with a focus on electrocatalytic water-splitting for hydrogen production, as well as the catalytic challenges of production of chemicals for the whole value chain using biomass, CO2 and plastic waste as raw materials. This article is part of the discussion meeting issue 'Green carbon for the chemical industry of the future'.
Chemistry Goes Green.

James H. Clark

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nchem.146

IF: 24.274

2009-01-01

Nature Chemistry

Abstract:Diminishing fossil fuel reserves, hazardous chemicals and wasteful processes have led to the emergence of 'green' technologies; James H. Clark at the University of York considers how metals, materials and organic compounds can be prepared by clean and sustainable routes.
Untangling the chemical complexity of plastics to improve life cycle outcomes

Kara Lavender Law,Margaret J Sobkowicz,Michael P Shaver,Mark E Hahn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41578-024-00705-x

Abstract:A diversity of chemicals are intentionally added to plastics to enhance their properties and aid in manufacture. Yet, the accumulated chemical composition of these materials is essentially unknown even to those within the supply chain, let alone to consumers or recyclers. Recent legislated and voluntary commitments to increase recycled content in plastic products highlight the practical challenges wrought by these chemical mixtures, amid growing public concern about the impacts of plastic-associated chemicals on environmental and human health. In this Perspective, we offer guidance for plastics manufacturers to collaborate across sectors and critically assess their use of added chemicals. The ultimate goal is to use fewer and better additives to promote a circular plastics economy with minimal risk to humans and the environment.
Green Chemistry, Catalysis, and Waste Valorization for a Circular Economy

Chularat Wattanakit,Xiaolei Fan,Rino R. Mukti,Alex C. K. Yip

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cplu.202400389

2024-07-19

ChemPlusChem

Abstract:This Special Collection highlights recent advancements in green chemistry, catalysis, and waste valorization, fields critical for achieving sustainable practices and resource efficiency within a circular economy. It showcases examples of effective catalysts with the potential to enhance resource conservation and circularity and convert waste and biomass materials into valuable products. The circular economy represents an economic model that prioritizes sustainability and resource efficiency, aiming to minimize waste minimization, promote reuse, and close material loops. This Special Collection highlights recent advancements in green chemistry, catalysis, and waste valorization, fields critical for achieving sustainable practices and resource efficiency within a circular economy. Researchers from the Asia‐Pacific region, Europe, South America, and North America have contributed to designing sustainable chemical processes that minimize environmental impact. These efforts involve developing efficient reactions to reduce waste generation and resource depletion. Additionally, this Special Collection showcases examples of effective catalysts with the potential to enhance resource conservation and circularity and convert waste and biomass materials into valuable products.

chemistry, multidisciplinary
Digitalization paving the ways for sustainable chemistry: switching on more green lights

Vânia Zuin Zeidler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adq3537

IF: 56.9

2024-06-15

Science

Abstract:The world is facing an interconnected crisis caused by a variety of factors including climate change, water scarcity, biodiversity loss, and chemical waste. One of most prominent factors is the exploitation of limited resources to convert them into chemical products based on the traditional linear approach. This has been provocatively described as rubbish chemistry , a "bad, old-school" system that needs to be revised globally. Representing one of the largest and most complex industrial sectors around the globe and accounting for $4 trillion USD in sales in 2019, the chemical industry generates fundamental components to produce agrochemicals, plastics, paints, adhesives, coatings, electronics, and pharmaceuticals. However, most of these chemicals are made using oil and natural gas , corresponding to 99% of the feedstocks for downstream organic chemical production. Over 80% of the producing companies assert that sustainability has become as important to them as revenue growth, and both increasingly depend on recent advancements in digitalization .

multidisciplinary sciences
Designing a circular carbon and plastics economy for a sustainable future

Fernando Vidal,Eva R. van der Marel,Ryan W. F. Kerr,Caitlin McElroy,Nadia Schroeder,Celia Mitchell,Gloria Rosetto,Thomas T. D. Chen,Richard M. Bailey,Cameron Hepburn,Catherine Redgwell,Charlotte K. Williams

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-06939-z

IF: 64.8

2024-02-01

Nature

Abstract:The linear production and consumption of plastics today is unsustainable. It creates large amounts of unnecessary and mismanaged waste, pollution and carbon dioxide emissions, undermining global climate targets and the Sustainable Development Goals. This Perspective provides an integrated technological, economic and legal view on how to deliver a circular carbon and plastics economy that minimizes carbon dioxide emissions. Different pathways that maximize recirculation of carbon (dioxide) between plastics waste and feedstocks are outlined, including mechanical, chemical and biological recycling, and those involving the use of biomass and carbon dioxide. Four future scenarios are described, only one of which achieves sufficient greenhouse gas savings in line with global climate targets. Such a bold system change requires 50% reduction in future plastic demand, complete phase-out of fossil-derived plastics, 95% recycling rates of retrievable plastics and use of renewable energy. It is hard to overstate the challenge of achieving this goal. We therefore present a roadmap outlining the scale and timing of the economic and legal interventions that could possibly support this. Assessing the service lifespan and recoverability of plastic products, along with considerations of sufficiency and smart design, can moreover provide design principles to guide future manufacturing, use and disposal of plastics.

multidisciplinary sciences
The Critical Role of Process Analysis in Chemical Recycling and Upcycling of Waste Plastics.

Avantika Singh,A. Carpenter,Yuriy Román‐Leshkov,Scott R Nicholson,G. Beckham,Julie E. Rorrer,Nicholas A. Rorrer,A. J. Jacobsen,Mikhail O. Konev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-chembioeng-100521-085846

2022-02-23

Annual Review of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering

Abstract:There is an urgent need for new technologies to enable circularity for synthetic polymers, spurred by the accumulation of waste plastics in landfills and the environment and the contributions of plastics manufacturing to climate change. Chemical recycling is a promising means to convert waste plastics into molecular intermediates that can be remanufactured into new products. Given the growing interest in the development of new chemical recycling approaches, it is critical to evaluate the economics, energy use, greenhouse gas emissions, and other life cycle inventory metrics for emerging processes, relative to the incumbent, linear manufacturing practices employed today. Here we offer specific definitions for classes of chemical recycling and upcycling and describe general process concepts for the chemical recycling of mixed plastics waste. We present a framework for techno-economic analysis and life cycle assessment for both closed- and open-loop chemical recycling. Rigorous application of these process analysis tools will be required to enable impactful solutions for the plastics waste problem. Expected final online publication date for the Annual Review of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Volume 13 is October 2022. Please see http://www.annualreviews.org/page/journal/pubdates for revised estimates.

Medicine,Chemistry,Engineering,Environmental Science
The role of chemical and solvent-based recycling within a sustainable circular economy for plastics

Magdalena Klotz,Christopher Oberschelp,Cecilia Salah,Luc Subal,Stefanie Hellweg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.167586

2024-01-01

Abstract:Chemical and solvent-based recycling of plastic waste may help overcome some of the challenges faced by predominantly applied mechanical recycling techniques. This study quantifies the environmental impacts of chemical and solvent-based recycling as a function of varying process parameters and product composition using life cycle assessment. Furthermore, potential benefits and impacts on a system level are determined. To that end, a high-resolution material flow analysis is conducted for the reference system of Switzerland, covering all main plastic types and applications. In a scenario for the year 2040, we employ environmentally beneficial mechanical recycling where possible and convey suitable remaining waste streams to chemical or solvent-based recycling processes. Applying chemical or solvent-based recycling as a complement to maximum mechanical recycling, instead of thermal treatment with energy recovery, may achieve a reduction in the climate change impact of the system ranging from less than 10 % to almost 40 %. For achieving high environmental benefits, proper process choice and configuration are crucial. Dissolution or depolymerization provide higher benefits relative to other chemical recycling processes, but can only treat certain waste streams and require prior sorting into plastic types. Pyrolysis and gasification appeared to only have the ability to achieve substantial benefits over incineration if their output products can substitute high-impact chemicals and provided that efficient heat transfer and recovery is warranted when implemented on a large scale. As industrial-scale plants for chemical or solvent-based plastic recycling are still lacking, the upscaling potential and the environmental benefits achievable in practice are highly uncertain today.
From Waste to Wealth Using Green Chemistry: the Way to Long Term Stability

James H. Clark

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cogsc.2017.07.008

IF: 9.3

2017-01-01

Current Opinion in Green and Sustainable Chemistry

Abstract:Waste is an extremely valuable resource that we have been accumulating over a long period. Interesting and viable organic “waste-to-resource” opportunities include plastics and food supply chain wastes. Their use as chemical feedstocks will fit well with a circular economy model. Plastics is a major waste opportunity: worldwide we only recycle a few % of the plastic we use, yet plastic manufacturing consumes some 10% of all the oil we consume, and much of it causes serious environmental damage through negligent release. The chemical content of food supply chain wastes are much more complex and varied than in plastic waste but offers a wide range of valuable chemical products. Bio-refineries can be defined as integrated complexes in which a number of renewable-derived feedstocks (bio-waste, biomass) can be converted in a range of useful products including chemicals, materials and fuels similar and sometimes identical to those obtained from petroleum.
A review on recent environmental electrochemistry approaches for the consolidation of a circular economy model

Gustavo Acosta-Santoyo,José Treviño-Reséndez,Irma Robles,Luis A Godínez,Josué D García-Espinoza

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2023.140573

IF: 8.8

Chemosphere

Abstract:Availability of raw materials in the chemical industry is related to the selection of the chemical processes in which they are used as well as to the efficiency, cost, and eventual evolution to more competitive dynamics of transformation technologies. In general terms however, any chemically transforming technology starts with the extraction, purification, design, manufacture, use, and disposal of materials. It is important to create a new paradigm towards green chemistry, sustainability, and circular economy in the chemical sciences that help to better employ, reuse, and recycle the materials used in every aspect of modern life. Electrochemistry is a growing field of knowledge that can help with these issues to reduce solid waste and the impact of chemical processes on the environment. Several electrochemical studies in the last decades have benefited the recovery of important chemical compounds and elements through electrodeposition, electrowinning, electrocoagulation, electrodialysis, and other processes. The use of living organisms and microorganisms using an electrochemical perspective (known as bioelectrochemistry), is also calling attention to "mining", through plants and microorganisms, essential chemical elements. New process design or the optimization of the current technologies is a major necessity to enhance production and minimize the use of raw materials along with less generation of wastes and secondary by-products. In this context, this contribution aims to show an up-to-date scenario of both environmental electrochemical and bioelectrochemical processes for the extraction, use, recovery and recycling of materials in a circular economy model.

Rethinking Chemistry for a Circular Economy

Circular economy design considerations for research and process development in the chemical sciences

Circular Economy and Green Chemistry: The Need for Radical Innovative Approaches in the Design for New Products

Designing for a green chemistry future

Beyond Reductionist Thinking in Chemistry for Sustainability

Catalysis for Carbon‐Circularity: Emerging Concepts and Role of Inorganic Chemistry

Chemical Industry and Circular Economy

Modern chemistry is rubbish

Using Green Chemistry to Progress a Circular Fashion Industry

Circularity in polymers: addressing performance and sustainability challenges using dynamic covalent chemistries

Circularity in mixed-plastic chemical recycling enabled by variable rates of polydiketoenamine hydrolysis

Contributions of heterogeneous catalysis enabling resource efficiency and circular economy

Chemistry Goes Green.

Untangling the chemical complexity of plastics to improve life cycle outcomes

Green Chemistry, Catalysis, and Waste Valorization for a Circular Economy

Digitalization paving the ways for sustainable chemistry: switching on more green lights

Designing a circular carbon and plastics economy for a sustainable future

The Critical Role of Process Analysis in Chemical Recycling and Upcycling of Waste Plastics.

The role of chemical and solvent-based recycling within a sustainable circular economy for plastics

From Waste to Wealth Using Green Chemistry: the Way to Long Term Stability

A review on recent environmental electrochemistry approaches for the consolidation of a circular economy model