A Comparative Investigation Of Several Calculation Codes For Plume Rising Height In South China

Fei-Lin Hao,Ming-Wei Shen
2016-01-01
Abstract:In order to explore the suitable calculation code for rising height of the plume from the industrial chimney in the surrounding areas of Hangzhou, eight widely accepted empirical formulas were used to calculate for a local cooperation's stack. Meanwhile, the actual plume's rising heights were measured in the site under sunny, cloudy and rainy weather conditions, the comparison shows that huge difference among the eight results with a variation from 1 to 9 times of the measured value, the TVA formula, Gu Qing formula and Briggs formula calculate out the biggest three rising heights, which are all higher than the measured data with averaged relative errors of 873%, 373% and 316% respectively under three weather conditions. For the condition of measurement in this article, the Holland formula exhibits the minimum averaged relative error of 20.94%, and for the cloudy, sunny and rainy weather conditions, the Lucas formula, the Holland formula and the Concawe formula calculate the minimum relative error respectively. As a comparison, a new calculation method was developed based on the Eulerian multiphase flow theory and conducted via computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method, the results is a 4.76% of averaged relative error between the measured and simulated data under three weather conditions, and a variation of 2.80%similar to 10.03% for relative error. The comparison shows that choosing the appropriate formula is critical for plume height calculation and the CFD method exhibits the most stable performance for this case.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?