Abstract:In humans, sleep spindles are 10- to 16-Hz oscillations lasting approximately 0.5-2 s. Spindles, along with cortical slow oscillations, may facilitate memory consolidation by enabling synaptic plasticity. Early recordings of spindles at the scalp found anterior channels had overall slower frequency than central-posterior channels. This robust, topographical finding led to dichotomizing spindles as "slow" versus "fast," modeled as two distinct spindle generators in frontal versus posterior cortex. Using a large dataset of intracranial stereoelectroencephalographic (sEEG) recordings from 20 patients (13 female, 7 male) and 365 bipolar recordings, we show that the difference in spindle frequency between frontal and parietal channels is comparable to the variability in spindle frequency within the course of individual spindles, across different spindles recorded by a given site, and across sites within a given region. Thus, fast and slow spindles only capture average differences that obscure a much larger underlying overlap in frequency. Furthermore, differences in mean frequency are only one of several ways that spindles differ. For example, compared with parietal, frontal spindles are smaller, tend to occur after parietal when both are engaged, and show a larger decrease in frequency within-spindles. However, frontal and parietal spindles are similar in being longer, less variable, and more widespread than occipital, temporal, and Rolandic spindles. These characteristics are accentuated in spindles which are highly phase-locked to posterior hippocampal spindles. We propose that rather than a strict parietal-fast/frontal-slow dichotomy, spindles differ continuously and quasi-independently in multiple dimensions, with variability due about equally to within-spindle, within-region, and between-region factors.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Sleep spindles are 10- to 16-Hz neural oscillations generated by cortico-thalamic circuits that promote memory consolidation. Spindles are often dichotomized into slow-anterior and fast-posterior categories for cognitive and clinical studies. Here, we show that the anterior-posterior difference in spindle frequency is comparable to that observed between different cycles of individual spindles, between spindles from a given site, or from different sites within a region. Further, we show that spindles vary on other dimensions such as duration, amplitude, spread, primacy and consistency, and that these multiple dimensions vary continuously and largely independently across cortical regions. These findings suggest that multiple continuous variables rather than a strict frequency dichotomy may be more useful biomarkers for memory consolidation or psychiatric disorders.

Human Spindle Variability

Spindle oscillations are generated in the dorsal thalamus and modulated by the thalamic reticular nucleus

Individualized temporal patterns dominate cortical upstate and sleep depth in driving human sleep spindle timing

Brain Activations Time Locked to Slow Wave-Coupled Sleep Spindles Correlates with Intellectual Abilities

Sleep Spindles and Intellectual Ability: Epiphenomenon or Directly Related?

BRAIN ACTIVATION TIME-LOCKED TO SLEEP SPINDLES ASSOCIATED WITH HUMAN COGNITIVE ABILITIES

Coupling of slow oscillations in prefrontal and motor cortex predicts onset of spindle trains and persistent memory reactivations

0074 Sleep Slow Oscillations Differ in Depth Profiles Based on Their Coupling with Spindles: A Classification Study

Spindle oscillations in communicating axons within a reconstituted hippocampal formation are strongest in CA3 without thalamus

0086 Good quality sleep facilitates psychomotor learning via fast spindles among older adults

Coupling of Slow Oscillations in the Prefrontal and Motor Cortex Predicts Onset of Spindle Trains and Persistent Memory Reactivations

Spatiotemporal patterns of sleep spindle activity in human anterior thalamus and cortex

Functional differences in cerebral activation between slow wave-coupled and uncoupled sleep spindles

Sleep spindle architecture associated with distinct clinical phenotypes in older adults at risk for dementia

Interindividual sleep spindle differences and their relation to learning-related enhancements

Slow Sleep Spindle Activity, Declarative Memory, and General Cognitive Abilities in Children

Sleep Spindle-dependent Functional Connectivity Correlates with Cognitive Abilities.

Posterior Hippocampal Spindle Ripples Co-occur with Neocortical Theta Bursts and Downstates-Upstates, and Phase-Lock with Parietal Spindles During NREM Sleep in Humans

Pulsed inhibition of corticospinal excitability by the thalamocortical sleep spindle

The timing of sleep spindles is modulated by the respiratory cycle in humans

A mechanism for learning with sleep spindles