The Discovery of the Antioxidant Function of Vitamin E : the Contribution of
H. A. Mattill
Abstract:The history of vitamin E in its function as an antioxidant illustrates the development of a concept and shows how a new idea can arise from a change in the interpretation of preexisting experimental results. The best-established biochemical function of vitamin E is its action as a lipid antioxidant. In the history of nutrition, the discoverer of the antioxidant function of vitamin E, H. A. Mattill, has been somewhat neglected. Thus, the distinguished vitamin E researcher Karl E. Mason (1) wrote in 1980: “The pioneer studies of Mattill and his colleagues deserved more recognition than they received.” Henry Albright Mattill was born in Glasgow, Missouri, in 1883 (2). He received his A.B. degree from Adelbert College, Western Reserve University, and his Ph.D. in physiological chemistry from the University of Illinois in 1910. He taught physiological chemistry at the University of Utah from 1910 to 1915 and nutrition at the University of California at Berkeley, 1915–1918. After a stint as a major in the division of food and nutrition of the U.S. army during World War I, he became professor of biochemistry in the department of vital economics at the University of Rochester with John Merlin in 1919, and advanced to professor of biochemistry and head of the department at the University of Iowa in 1927, where he remained until his death in 1953. H. A. Mattill was president of the American Society of Biological Chemists in 1952. His principal work was in the area of vitamin E as a reproductive factor and as an antioxidant. In his later years he studied the metabolic functions of vitamin E in muscle. In 1920 Mattill and Conklin (3) investigated milk as the “perfect food” and wanted to determine “whether milk could continue to be an adequate food for the whole span of life or whether it is lacking in some factor necessary for the normal performance of physiological function.” They fed a diet of fresh whole milk to rats for their whole life span. The rats grew well initially; after d 50, growth declined and the females did not reproduce. Given whole dried milk, obtained commercially, food consumption was greater than with fresh milk, growth was normal, but there was no reproduction. When 10% butterfat was added to the diet, replacing that amount of starch, the rats were still sterile. Then, in 1923, Mattill and Stone (4) proposed the hypothesis that milk might contain a substance inhibitory to reproduction. They fed a series of rats diets containing 50, 60, 70, and 80% whole dried milk, 10% lard, 2% salts, and starch “in order to determine whether the dilution of an inhibitory factor in milk could turn reproductive failure into success.” However, reproduction was not successful with any of these diets. The authors (4) gave no reason for the relatively high level of lard (10%) in their diet, except that they wanted to use the diet devised by Osborne and Mendel (5) in their pioneering use of rats to investigate essential food factors in milk. At the time Mattill investigated the effect of milk diets on reproduction, Herbert M. Evans, an endocrinologist who had published the definitive work on “The Oestrous Cycle in the Rat” (6), and was aware of the recent discoveries of vitamins A, B and C, “proposed now to look into whether reproduction might have nutritive dependencies different in character from those adequate for growth to adulthood” (7). Together with Katharine S. Bishop (8), they found that rats fed a purified diet of casein 18%, cornstarch 54%, lard 15%, butterfat 9%, and salts 4%, adequate vitamin A (as cod liver oil), vitamin B (as yeast), vitamin C (as orange juice), did not reproduce. In females, although the ovaries, ovulation, and implantation were unimpaired, the defect resided in the placental function. In males, there was complete atrophy of the seminiferous 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: retinol@nature.berkeley.edu. Henry A. Mattill (1883–1953) Department of Special Collections Archives, University of Iowa Libraries