0052 Recovery Nap After Total Sleep Deprivation Restores Emotional Memory Performance to Typically-Rested Levels

Tony Cunningham,Dan Denis,Ryan Bottary,Elizabeth Kensinger,Shengzi Zeng,Robert Stickgold
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsae067.0052
IF: 6.313
2024-04-20
SLEEP
Abstract:Abstract Introduction While a brief period of recovery sleep can ameliorate the negative impacts of total sleep deprivation (TSD) on cognitive functioning, the effects of post-TSD recovery sleep on different forms of emotional functioning remain equivocal. Here, we investigated the effects of TSD and post-TSD recovery sleep on emotional memory processing and compared it to typical functioning in a rested condition. Methods During encoding of the emotional memory trade-off (ETO) task, participants viewed scenes with negative or neutral central objects overlaid on neutral backgrounds. During recognition, the central objects and backgrounds were presented separately and participants were asked to identify each of them as ‘Old’ or ‘New’. Forty-six participants in the TSD condition and 22 participants in the Sleep condition completed encoding the morning after the sleep manipulation (~10:00) and a recognition test was conducted on half of the scene components after a short delay (Recog_1, ~10:45). Twenty of the TSD participants were then given a 90-min nap opportunity (TSD_Nap). Participants then completed a second recognition test on the remaining images (Recog_2, ~14:00). Results At Recog_1, a group effect revealed significantly worse memory after TSD compared to Sleep (p=.02). Specifically, memory was significantly worse for every scene component except neutral objects, and there were no baseline differences between TSD_nap and TSD_NoNap participants. At Recog_2, memory continued to deteriorate for all scene components in the TSD_NoNap group compared to their Recog_1 performance (all p’s< 0.025). The TSD_nap group, however, had no change in memory for any of the neutral scene components and had improved negative object memory (p=.049) driven by a reduced false alarm rate (p<.001). As such, performance in the TSD_nap group matched the Sleep group at Recog_2 (all p’s>0.1). Conclusion These results demonstrate that post-TSD recovery sleep preserves and restores memory functioning such that performance matches typically-rested individuals – while extended TSD leads to continued deterioration – highlighting the importance of sleep in healthy emotional memory functioning. Additionally, the ETO effect (i.e., greater disparity between negative objects and their paired backgrounds compared to neutral objects and their backgrounds) was preserved for both recognition tasks in all groups, demonstrating the strength of this memory phenomenon. Support (if any)
neurosciences,clinical neurology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper explores the impact of restorative naps on emotional memory processing after total sleep deprivation (TSD), and compares it with the performance under normal resting conditions. Specifically, the researchers hope to understand: 1. **Specific impacts of total sleep deprivation on emotional memory processing**: Does total sleep deprivation lead to a decline in the ability to process emotional memories? 2. **The effect of restorative naps**: After total sleep deprivation, can a short restorative nap restore or improve the ability to process emotional memories? 3. **Memory differences in different emotional contents**: Under the conditions of total sleep deprivation and restorative naps, are there differences in the memory performance of negative and neutral emotional contents? ### Research methods - **Participants**: 46 participants in the total sleep deprivation group (TSD) and 22 participants in the normal sleep group (Sleep). - **Experimental design**: - **Encoding phase**: Participants viewed scene pictures containing negative or neutral central objects in the morning (around 10:00), with a neutral background. - **First recognition test (Recog_1)**: Conducted at around 10:45 to test participants' memory of some scene components. - **Restorative nap**: 20 participants in the TSD group took a 90 - minute nap (TSD_Nap), and the remaining TSD group participants did not nap (TSD_NoNap). - **Second recognition test (Recog_2)**: Conducted at around 14:00 to test participants' memory of the remaining scene components. ### Main results - **Recog_1 phase**: The memory performance of the TSD group was significantly lower than that of the normal sleep group (p = 0.02). In particular, except for neutral objects, the TSD group had significantly worse memory for all scene components. - **Recog_2 phase**: - **TSD_NoNap group**: Memory continued to deteriorate, and the memory performance of all scene components decreased (all p - values < 0.025). - **TSD_Nap group**: The memory of neutral scene components did not change, while the memory of negative objects improved (p = 0.049), mainly because the false alarm rate decreased (p < 0.001). Therefore, the performance of the TSD_Nap group in the Recog_2 phase was comparable to that of the normal sleep group (all p - values > 0.1). ### Conclusions - **The role of restorative naps**: Restorative naps after total sleep deprivation can protect and restore memory function, making the performance return to the level of normally rested individuals. Long - term total sleep deprivation will lead to continuous deterioration of memory function. - **The intensity of the emotional memory phenomenon**: In all groups, the emotional memory trade - off effect (that is, the difference between negative objects and their paired backgrounds is greater than the difference between neutral objects and their paired backgrounds) was preserved in both recognition tests, indicating that the intensity of this memory phenomenon is high. ### Formulas This article does not involve specific mathematical formulas, but mentions some statistical significance levels, such as: - \( p = 0.02 \) - \( p < 0.025 \) - \( p = 0.049 \) - \( p < 0.001 \) These p - values are used to evaluate the statistical significance of the experimental results.