Abstract:Although economists have suggested that humans generally prioritize maximizing their own self-interest rather than others' when distributing rewards, recent psychological studies have shown that people are hyperaltruistic when allocating physical harm to themselves and others during moral decision-making. However, little is known about how the neurocognitive mechanisms underlying self-relevance modulate this behavioral tendency under different degrees of physical harm. This study adopted a moral decision-making task to investigate behavioral and neural processes during moral decision-making involving different levels of self-relevance and physical harm. Event-related potentials were measured while participants made trade-offs of different monetary gains for themselves against painful electric shocks experienced by the receivers (self, friend, or stranger). These results suggest that early anterior N1, indexing fast and automatic moral intuitional process, decreased during the strong conflict trade-off decisions involving strong painful electric shocks and much monetary gains. Lower self-relevance enhanced the aversive experience and increased the mental cost of resolving moral conflict, reflected by a larger P260-LPP (300-450 ms) effect during weaker conflict decisions toward strangers than themselves and friends. However, this effect was weaker during strong conflict decisions. When making decisions about whether to shock others to gain money for themselves, participants were hyperaltruistic, foregoing greater self-interest to restrain harm directed toward strangers than themselves or friends. These findings shed light on the neural basis of the tension between egoistic and altruistic tendencies during moral decision-making integrating benefits and harms.

Money Gained Through Suffering is Less Valuable: Pain Reduces the Sensitivity to Outcome Magnitude in Monetary Decision Making.

Perceived Social Support Reduces the Pain of Spending Money

The Symbolic Power of Money

Physical Pain Induces Negative Person Perception

Pain modulates brain potentials and behavioral responses to unfairness

When your pain signifies my gain: neural activity while evaluating outcomes based on another person's pain.

Electrophysiological Evidence for the Effects of Pain on the Different Stages of Reward Evaluation under a Purchasing Situation.

The role of chronic pain and pain anxiety in delay discounting of pain and monetary losses

Beyond pain: modeling decision-making deficits in chronic pain

Differential effects of real versus hypothetical monetary reward magnitude on risk-taking behavior and brain activity

An Additional Gain Can Make You Feel Bad and an Additional Loss Can Make You Feel Good

Empathic neural responses to others' pain depend on monetary reward.

Real and hypothetical monetary rewards modulate risk taking in the brain

Attitude Toward Money Modulates Outcome Processing: an ERP Study.

Neural Responses to Perceived Pain in Others Predict Real-Life Monetary Donations in Different Socioeconomic Contexts

Repetition suppression between monetary loss and social pain

The Influence of Psychological Pain on Purchase Decision under Different Price Contexts: an EEG Study.

Reconciling Loss Aversion and Gain Seeking in Judged Emotions

Relationship between behavioral and mood responses to monetary rewards in a sample of Indian students with and without reported pain

Neural correlations of the influence of self-relevance on moral decision-making involving a trade-off between harm and reward

Physical Pain Increases Interpersonal Trust in Females.