Abstract:The robustness is an important functionality of networks because it manifests the ability of networks to resist failures or attacks. Many robustness measures have been proposed from different aspects, which provide us various ways to evaluate the network robustness. However, whether these measures can properly evaluate the network robustness and which aspects of network robustness these measures can evaluate are still open questions. Therefore, in this paper, a thorough introduction over attacks and robustness measures is first given, and then nine widely used robustness measures are comparatively studied. To validate whether a robustness measure can evaluate the network robustness properly, the sensitivity of robustness measures is first studied on both initial and optimized networks. Then, the performance of robustness measures in guiding the optimization process is studied, where both the optimization process and the obtained optimized networks are studied. The experimental results show that, first, the robustness measures are more sensitive to the changes in initial networks than to those in optimized networks; second, an optimized network may not be useful in practical situations because some useful functionalities, such as the shortest path length and communication efficiency, are sacrificed too much to improve the robustness; third, the robustness of networks in terms of closely correlated robustness measures can often be improved together. These results indicate that it is not wise to just apply the optimized networks obtained by optimizing over one certain robustness measure into practical situations. Practical requirements should be considered, and optimizing over two or more Received February 22, 2016; accepted September 29, 2016 E-mail: neouma@163.com suitable robustnessmeasures simultaneously is also a promising way.

Graph measures and network robustness

Graph Metrics for Internet Robustness -- A Survey

On Measuring Network Robustness for Weighted Networks

Structural Robustness and Vulnerability of Networks

Structural Robustness of Complex Networks: A Survey of A Posteriori Measures [Feature]

Structural Robustness of Complex Networks: A Survey of A Posteriori Measures

Robustness Analysis of the Complex Network

Spectral measure of robustness for internet topology

Correlation of Centralities: A Study Through Distinct Graph Robustness

Inconsistencies Among Spectral Robustness Metrics.

Bmnr: Design and Implementation A Benchmark for Metrics of Network Robustness

Study on Indices of Network Structure Robustness and Their Application

A Comparative Study of Network Robustness Measures

Spectral Measure of Robustness in Complex Networks

ELASTICITY: Topological Characterization of Robustness in Complex Networks

Robustness Measurement of Multiplex Networks Based on Graph Spectrum

Network Robustness Analysis Based on Maximum Flow

Measures and Optimization for Robustness and Vulnerability in Disconnected Networks

The Evaluation of Complex Networks' Robustness Based on Entropy Measure

A complex network approach to robustness and vulnerability of spatially organized water distribution networks

Hardness Analysis and Empirical Studies of the Relations among Robustness, Topology and Flow in Dynamic Networks