A Review on Envy in Workplace
LYU Yi-jing,PENG He
2014-01-01
Abstract:Management scholars usually neglect to study envy because it is contrary to the social moral law.Only recently management scholars have begun to pay attention to this area.Envy is defined as an unpleasant and often painful blend of feelings characterized by inferiority,hostility,and resentment caused by a comparison with a person or group of persons who possess something we desire.Researches on envy are extensive in the field of psychology,but are still very scarce in the field of organizational behavior.Since envy is quite prevalent in the workplace,and it would probably cause severe problems,it is never wise to avoid or ignore such a significant phenomenon.In order to better understand workplace envy and further advance researches in this field,we first illustrate the definition and the requisite of envy,and then clarify the difference between workplace envy and some related concepts,such as jealousy and admiration.We also summarize the determinants and outcomes of workplace envy in this paper.The results show that the emergence of workplace envy has three basic conditions.First,there must be a person or a group of persons who have better performance or achievements in some way or in some field;Second,the outstanding field the person or the group of persons possess must be important to the self;Third,the object of comparison usually have some similarities with the self.Although envy is prevalent in workplace,it not only harms the self-image,but also violates the social norms.As a result,it is quite common for people to deny their envy emotion,or even try to suppress such an emotion.Referring to the differentiation of envy and related concepts,we found that although envy and jealousy are usually used interchangeably in daily life,they are actually two totally different concepts.Envy is an emotion derived from social comparison,while jealousy is an emotion concerned with threat and fear of the loss of intimacy.Moreover,envy and admiration are two different concepts as well.Admiration is not a benign envy as some scholars have ever argued.They are different in that envy is a painful emotion derived from social comparison,while admiration is a positive emotion developed in the process of social comparison.With regard to the determinants and outcomes of workplace envy,we summarized all the theory models in previous literature,and got a relatively clear understanding of workplace envy.For the determinants of envy,we separated the determinants of workplace envy into two parts:individual factors and contextual factors.For the individual factors part,systematical review of extant literature shows that dispositional envy,neuroticism,conscientiousness,Machiavellianism,self-esteem,gratitude disposition,similarity,others' superiority,self-relevance,and justice perception are all potential triggers or suppressors of workplace envy.On the other hand,LMX,relatedness,and competitiveness are contextual factors that exert effects on the occurrence of workplace envy.As for the outcomes of envy,we also conducted systematical review and summarized that workplace envy would exert positive influences on counterproductive behavior but negative influences on organizational citizenship behavior.However,the effects of workplace envy on prosocial behavior and job performance are rather confused.Further investigation shows that core self evaluation and perceived organizational support play as important moderators in the relationship between envy and job performance,which help explain the unclear effects envy exerts on job performance.However,the effects between envy and prosocial behavior still stay inconsistent and ambiguous.More research is needed to further explain and empirically test the relationship between envy and prosocial behavior.In conclusion,we argued that future research should focus on clarifying the definition and classification of workplace envy,especially for some controversial concepts such as dispositional envy,episodic envy,benign envy,and malicious envy.Moreover,further research should be done for the discussion of determinants and outcomes of workplace envy,since there are still a lot of gaps.Furthermore,the mediating mechanisms through which envy exerts influences has not been well explored,so we also call for further researches in investigating the black box of workplace envy.Finally,we contend that workplace envy occurs both at individual level as well as group level.The effect of group dynamics will differentiate individual envy with group envy,so an extension of workplace envy to group level is also needs in this perspective.