Abstract:In our previous study, we compared the effect of action learning and perception learning when the stimulus was made invisible by continuous flash suppression. One group of participants was trained to insert a card into an invisible open rectangle (“action training”) that was either vertical or horizontal, and another group was trained to orally report the orientation of the invisible open rectangle (“perceptual training”). Before and after training, they were tested in three tasks to examine the effect of learning: 1) contrast sensitivity, 2) action performance (i.e., insert card), and 3) perception performance (i.e., oral report). We found that action learning decreased the contrast sensitivity of the stimulus and improved the action and perceptual performance, however, perception learning did not generate significant changes in any of the three tasks. In this study, visual feedback was provided by showing the stimulus to the participant after they performed the task in each trial. Therefore, it is possible that participants learned the association between the feedback stimulus and the response. To test this possibility, we conducted two more experiments, in which participants performed the same learning and test tasks as our previous study but received either no feedback (experiment 1) or an audio beep feedback when they responded incorrectly (experiment 2). We found that in both experiments, participants’ performance in all three tests was improved after action learning, and participants’ performance in contrast sensitivity and perception tests was improved after perception learning. Given that participants’ performance was not improved in perceptual learning with visual feedback, our study suggests that feedback is not necessary for unconscious action learning, but visual feedback negatively affects unconscious perception learning with oral reports.

The Influences of Feedback on Perceptual Category Learning and Its' Cognitive and Neurophysiological Mechanisms

Effects of the Observation Learning and the Feedback Learning on Category Learning

Comparing the effects of positive and negative feedback in information-integration category learning

Effect of Feedback Valence on Family Resemblance Category Learning

The Influence of Working Memory on Perceptual Category Learning: Problem and Conception

Effect of Feedback Value on Family Resemble Category Learning: An ERPs Study

The effect of feedback timing on category learning and feedback processing in younger and older adults

The Development of Category Learning Researches of Cognitive Neuroscience

Neural Correlates of Feedback Processing in Visuo-Tactile Crossmodal Paired-Associate Learning.

Feedback and observational learning differ in effectiveness during category learning in early school aged children and adults

Perceptual Learning Without Feedback in Non-Stationary Contexts: Data and Model

Differential destinations, dynamics, and functions of high- and low-order features in the feedback signal during object processing

Feedback needs experience

The effect of deferring feedback on rule-based and information-integration category learning.

Criterial Learning and Feedback Delay: Insights from Computational Models and Behavioral Experiments

Delayed feedback disrupts optimal strategies during foreign speech sound learning

Effects of Different Kinds of Feedback on Unconscious Action Learning and Unconscious Perception Learning

Informational feedback accelerates learning in multi-alternative perceptual judgements of orientation

Identifying Long- and Short-Term Processes in Perceptual Learning

The Multiple Systems Theory in Category Learning

Cognitive and Neural Mechanisms of Category-based Feature Inference