Preliminary Discussion on the Methods of Ascertainment of Foreign Laws

李旺

2003-01-01

Abstract:The legal systems of different countries are different in the aspect of the nature and the methods of ascertainment of foreign laws. The foreign laws are not equivalent to the domestic laws, and not facts as well. The legal institution of ex officio investigation can be adopted with respect to the methods of ascertainment of foreign laws.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Legal Reflection on Linking Up with International Usage

Kai Tao,Zheng Cheng

2002-01-01

Abstract:Legal system is one part of system which is linking up with the world in the course of China's being open to the world. There is still some misunderstanding about international usage. In this article,the author clarifies the meaning of internationalusage, discourses upon its legal character and function, sets forth the criterion of linking up with international usage, and discusses how to deal with the relationship between the international usage and the domestic law.
The Legal System of Concurrence of International Parallel Litigation of the U. S. A. Federal Court

李旺

2001-01-01

Abstract:The development of multinational economy brings about the continued increase of international civil and commercial disputes, which has great influence on international civil procedural law. Then, the concurrence of international parallel litigation is the result of positive conflicts of international jurisdiction over civil actions between different countries. Under the circumstances of today's being lack of a unified international treaty, how to realize effective regulation by domestic law of different countries becomes an important issue of international civil procedural law. The U.S.A. Federal Court has relevant legal system regulating the concurrence of international actions. Moreover, the study and use the American legal system for references will be greatly useful for the development of China's own systems.
Foreign Law:Fact or Law?

Song Xiao

2010-01-01

Abstract:In litigations involving foreign elements,two doctrines have been adopted.One refers to those systems that regard foreign law as law and the other refers to those systems that regard foreign law as fact.Neither of the two can provide theoretic basis for judicial practice in various states when coming to important issues in foreign laws,such as whether the rule of conflicts should be applied according to functions and powers,the legal consequence resulting from failure of ascertaining foreign laws,and remedies for wrong application of foreign laws.The fact doctrine or the law doctrine can only partly produce the corresponding method of ascertaining the content of foreign law.Such division is,to a great extent,artificial,and neither of the two doctrines has succeeded in providing an integrated method for the related issues concerning foreign laws.Today,efforts are needed to establish proper legal norms to resolve various concrete problems of foreign laws,instead of sticking to the abstract nature of foreign laws.
A Tentative Exploration into the Feasibility of Administration of Justice's Interference with Domestic Violence

李华

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-3698.2003.02.007

2003-01-01

Abstract:This article tends to discuss whether a country should interfere with domestic violence cases. Through introducing America s legislative and judicial reforms and development in the aspect of domestic violence and centering on the dispute about the famous not renouncing prosecution policy, the essay points out although there are some certain faults in the administration of justice's interference with domestic violence in China, in general, the advantages outweigh the disadvantages, hence, it is reasonable and practicable.
The Uncertainties in the Ascertainment of Foreign Law in Chinese Court: A Critical Analysis of the Current Mechanism

Xiaoyi Liao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.56397/le.2023.01.05

2023-01-01

Abstract:With the implementation of China’s “One Belt, One Road” Construction, China’s foreign-related civil and commercial disputes are characterized by an increase in the number and variety. As an important mechanism in the Private International Law field, ascertainment of foreign law is becoming increasingly prominent in resolving these disputes. However, broad statistics concerning the outcome of relevant cases show that the judicial practice of the Chinese mechanism on ascertainment of foreign law is unsatisfactory. To clarify the uncertainties existing in the current mechanism, we need to properly integrate and coordinate Chinese legislating and cases relating to this issue, further refine the matter like how to establish evidence for proving the content of the law, what forms of evidence is acceptable and how to assess the obtained evidence.

Law
Sources of Private International Law from a Comparative Law Perspective-A Concurrent Discussion on the Proposition That General International Usages Are Not Sources of PIL

陈卫佐

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-769x.2009.02.012

2009-01-01

Abstract:This article explores domestic and international sources of private international law from a comparative law perspective.Domestic sources include national statutory law,case law and customary law;whereas international sources are mainly bilateral and multilateral treaties.To address the question of whether international customs are sources of private international law,the present article differentiates and analyzes international customs and international usages,and points out that on this basis only international customary law rules have the binding force of law,which makes it possible for them to be sources of law.Due to a lack of the binding force of law,it is impossible for general international usages to be sources of law,let alone sources of private international law.
Some Fundamental Issues in the Theory of the Legal Method of Criminal law

王世洲

2005-01-01

Abstract:The legal method of criminal law is related to the specific issues and therefore falls into the scope of the criminal law studies. However, the methodology of criminal law is related to the Weltanschauung and therefore only belongs to the field of general jurisprudence studies. In criminal law studies, every kind of method has its own function and its limitation as well. It is impossible to complete any criminal law study only by one method. In constructing modern criminal law theory, the method of comparative study is the one our Chinese scholars shall pay special attention to; while the systematic method is the most important method. And the ideal of criminal law is of the fundamental guidance for choosing the legal method of criminal law. Based upon these understandings, the author holds that a comprehensive method should be the best method for criminal law.
On the Foundation of Interpretations of a Civil Law and the Application of Methods in the Interpretations

LIU Kai-xiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1673-1565.2006.02.005

2006-01-01

Abstract:Interpretations of a law include not only the explanations regarding the contents and meanings of a law when they are not explicit but also the judgments concerning whether there are such laws and regulations,as well as the supplements of values and loopholes in the law.Based on different subjects and different effects of the law,interpretations of a civil law differ as legislative interpretations,judicial interpretations and doctrinal interpretations.Different methods used in the interpretations of a law include literal methods,systematical ones,intentional ones,historical ones and comparative ones.The supplements of loopholes and interpretations of the legal provisions of a law sometimes cross each other and can not be distinguished from one another therefore it is necessary to analyze them.
On Legislation of Obligation of China's Judicial Institutions and Parties in Ascertainment of Foreign Law

Sun Jia

Abstract:Clear legislation of obligations of China's judicial institutions and parties in ascertainment of foreign law is not only the legal basis for the judicial institution and the parties concerned to fulfill their respective obligations of ascertainment, but also is the legal basis for checking whether they fulfill their obligations. It is directly related to the problem whether the foreign law that our country need apply and identify can be successfully identified and applied or not. However, there are still some problems in the current legislation of our country. There is no clear legislation of obligation subject of ascertainment of foreign law, no guiding ideology in the obligation subject of ascertainment, no rules for the ascertainment of our judicial institution in person, as well as the rules of the obligation of ascertainment of our judicial institution when the parties fail to provide foreign law are not reasonable.Now, the research on these issues in China is still not deep enough. The in-depth analysis on these issues is beneficial to further improve legislation of obligation of China's judicial institutions and parties in ascertainment of foreign law and develop the international civil and commercial relations in China coordinately.

Law,Political Science
Discussion on Research Methodology of Law of Evidence.

CHEN Rui-hua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1674-1226.2007.05.002

2007-01-01

Abstract:For the current jurisprudential research in China, theory and practice are virtually split into two different parts, which is not the result of lackness of data and documentations, but of the absence of scientific research method of Law of Evidence. We should reflect and treat the evidence legislation, law migration and speculative jurisprudence dialectically. From the perspective of methodology, the following three questions should be paid attention to during the development process of Law of Evidence: First, we should focus on the problems occurred in the real world. Second, the cause of problems should be identified and analyzed. Third, starting from the experience and lessons, we should spare no efforts to find out the in-depth problems and system problems, figuring out the underlying structure and resulting in conceptual theory.
On Evidential Burden in Criminal Charge ——A Comparison Between the View of Our Country and That of Anglo-American Law System Countries on Evidential Burden

Meng Li

2004-01-01

Abstract:The jurists in each country regard evident burden different from each other because of the difference of their action mode and historical habits. This author tries to compare the theory of on evidential burden between our country and Anglo-American law system countries from two aspects of substance and procedure, in order to be made use of by our country in the theory of evidential and legislative technique.
Problems in the Legal System of Foreign-Invested Enterprises and the Corresponding Measures

马忠法,李路根

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-2435.2004.05.014

2004-01-01

Abstract:There are problems in the revised laws of foreign-invested enterprises. They conflict with the related laws and regulations and rules seriously. “supra-national treatment” exists widely. The inconsistence between laws of foreign-invested enterprises and the laws on market subjects as company laws have not been changed essentially. These problems have brought negative effects to the implementation of laws of foreign-invested enterprises and the construction of its legal environment. Therefore, measures should be taken to revise and perfect them, enhance the quality of legislation, unify the legal institutions and build up the authority of laws and regulations.
On the Foreign Arbitral awards Dispute without Foreign Elements

Li Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-8207.2013.10.027

2013-01-01

Abstract:The agreement between the two parties' will no foreign factors play in foreign dispute arbitration agreement shall be determined according to the applicable law of arbitration agreement,rather than directly according to the Chinese law determined invalid.According to the current law,if there are no circumstances listed by the Article 5 of the "New York Convention",the foreign arbitral awards without foreign elements controversial should be given the recognition and enforcement by our court.Meanwhile,the domestic dispute shall be prohibited foreign arbitration.Referring to the U.S.practice,we can confirm that "New York Convention" cannot be applied to foreign arbitration between domestic parties,unless the applicant provides evidence of out-of-state property or substantial connection to the dispute relation.
The Research Methods Concerning the Status and Function of Civil Law, Commercial Law and Economical Law

Bao-shu WANG

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-2397.2008.03.001

2008-01-01

Abstract:To assess the status of civil law,commercial law and economical law scientifically tends to help people to gain a clearer prospective of the laws while bringing to light the fact that the status of the three laws varies does not mean that they are demarcated clearly from each other.The greater the status of the three laws varies,the more urgent their harmonization,interaction and complementation are.Thus,it is more necessary for us to find out the features of the three laws so as let them to play fully and coordinately their roles in regulating social relations and solving major social problems.The ultimate purpose of assessing the status of the three laws is to exploit their respective advantages while overcoming their shortcomings so as to ensure their coordination,interaction and complementation.
An Analysis on the Disputed Issues of the Applicable Law for Foreign-Related Contracts

JIAO Yan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-8860.2011.04.019

2011-01-01

Abstract:The newly adopted act on The Law Applicable to Foreign-Related Civil Relationships only provides general rules for the applicable law of foreign-related contracts,leaving many issues vaguely enacted.Consequently,the former Judicial Interpretations still acts as the starting point in this field.The disputed issues include party autonomy,characteristic performance,the applicable law for special contracts and the matters governed by the applicable law of contract.Of the Judicial Interpretations,good rules should be kept,while flaws perfected and gaps filled by the future Judicial Interpretations.
Jurisdiction over Defendant's Property in Civil Case Involving Foreign Element: A Comparative Study

Yan Jiao

2011-01-01

Abstract:An absolute jurisdiction over a defendant’s property is provided by Civil Procedure Law ( 2007) and our judicial practice has followed the provision accordingly. However,in the field of jurisdiction in civil cases involving foreign element,such jurisdiction is a much controversial issue. A comparative study on this issue shall afford us not only experiences in relation to relevant systems theoretically,but also an understanding of acceptance by international community in this respect realistically. Systems of jurisdiction in Germany,US and European Brussels are the most influential ones involving foreign elements in the world. A comparative study shows that jurisdiction over defendant’s property is accepted traditionally,but generally,it has been subject to qualification and limitation in recent decades. From the perspective of realism,coupling the balance of interests of both plaintiff and defendant with expansion of jurisdiction by various states and the need to enforce foreign judgments,we should uphold jurisdiction over defendant’s property while imposing reasonable limitations on the basis of future changes within the system of jurisdiction involving foreign element.
On the Application of Chinese Labor Laws in the Foreign-related Labor Dispute

Liu Fengqi

Abstract:The stipulations on the applicable law to foreign-related labor relation in Chinese law are rather simple, and there are conflicts between the existing provisions.Foreign-related labor dispute is mainly governed by the law of country in which the employee carries out his work in performance of contract. In a case where an employee who works in China, dispute regarding his/her labor contract may be governed by Chinese labor and employment laws. However, it is a controversial problem that whether all of the mandatory rules in Chinese labor and employment laws should apply to the labor contract which the place of contract performance is in China. Foreign-related labor contract which the place of contract performance is outside of China may be governed by the foreign labor laws. While the labor standards in foreign law are lower than those in China, it can be directly governed by the mandatory rules in Chinese labor laws.

Economics,Law
The Different or the Same: the Different Kinds of Research Data's Value in Chinese Legal History

Qi-cheng LI

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15991/j.cnki.411028.2012.03.017

2012-01-01

Abstract:Since the establishment of Chinese legal history as a discipline at the turn of the 20th century,an agreement has been reached that different kinds of data have different values.This conclusion is drawn by Chinese scholars who combine traditional Chinese methods and western ones in their historical studies.The researchers have an inclination to consider all kinds of data equally important.This inclination has close ties with the researchers' historical view,the consciousness of the question and the style of research,so it's necessary to discriminate them.This tendency has impeded the goal of getting the truth,which is the researchers' first pursuit in their studies of Chinese legal history.On account of the rethinking profoundly on historical view,the consciousness of the question and the style of research,I think a more rational point on the value of the data must include these three parts:different kinds of data have different values,the researchers must think much of the familiar data and material object,pay attention to the reason why the new data is new and use them flexibly.
New Methods for Science of Law

Ben QIU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-7110.2015.02.001

2015-01-01

Abstract:Apart from the existing methods like value judgment, empirical analysis, social practice, legal interpretation, legal inference, and logical analysis, there are still other methods such as moving from"things"to"principle". Compared with the existing law methods, these new methods are not only innovation and development, but also more fundamental.
Research of evasion of law on the mandatory and prohibitive rules

Pengnian Jin,Dechang Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-0221.2006.03.021

2006-01-01

Abstract:To define and ascertain mandatory and prohibitive legal rules is a premise to the court applying ' evasion of law'into the private international law practice,but what mandatory and prohibitive rules are in the'evasion of law' is still blank on the academic theory.In order to enrich this theory and propose some suggestions,this paper is to enumerate mandatory and prohibitive legal rules and put forward some ascertainment standards to them based on the anal- ysis of some cases.Finally,the author expounds the relationship between ‘evasion of law’,‘direct applicable law’ and ‘pubic order’during process of application.

Preliminary Discussion on the Methods of Ascertainment of Foreign Laws

Legal Reflection on Linking Up with International Usage

The Legal System of Concurrence of International Parallel Litigation of the U. S. A. Federal Court

Foreign Law:Fact or Law?

A Tentative Exploration into the Feasibility of Administration of Justice's Interference with Domestic Violence

The Uncertainties in the Ascertainment of Foreign Law in Chinese Court: A Critical Analysis of the Current Mechanism

Sources of Private International Law from a Comparative Law Perspective-A Concurrent Discussion on the Proposition That General International Usages Are Not Sources of PIL

Some Fundamental Issues in the Theory of the Legal Method of Criminal law

On the Foundation of Interpretations of a Civil Law and the Application of Methods in the Interpretations

On Legislation of Obligation of China's Judicial Institutions and Parties in Ascertainment of Foreign Law

Discussion on Research Methodology of Law of Evidence.

On Evidential Burden in Criminal Charge ——A Comparison Between the View of Our Country and That of Anglo-American Law System Countries on Evidential Burden

Problems in the Legal System of Foreign-Invested Enterprises and the Corresponding Measures

On the Foreign Arbitral awards Dispute without Foreign Elements

The Research Methods Concerning the Status and Function of Civil Law, Commercial Law and Economical Law

An Analysis on the Disputed Issues of the Applicable Law for Foreign-Related Contracts

Jurisdiction over Defendant's Property in Civil Case Involving Foreign Element: A Comparative Study

On the Application of Chinese Labor Laws in the Foreign-related Labor Dispute

The Different or the Same: the Different Kinds of Research Data's Value in Chinese Legal History

New Methods for Science of Law

Research of evasion of law on the mandatory and prohibitive rules