Abstract:A classic issue in the cognitive psychology of human category learning has involved the contrast between exemplar and prototype models. However, experimental tests to distinguish the models have relied almost solely on use of artificially-constructed categories composed of simplified stimuli. Here we contrast the predictions from the models in a real-world natural-science category domain—geologic rock types. Previous work in this domain used a set of complementary methods, including multidimensional scaling and direct dimension ratings, to derive a high-dimensional feature space in which the rock stimuli are embedded. The present work compares the category-learning predictions of exemplar and prototype models that make reference to this derived feature space. The experiments include conditions that should be favorable to prototype abstraction, including use of multiple large-size categories, delayed transfer testing, and real-world category structures. Nevertheless, the results of the qualitative and quantitative model comparisons point toward the exemplar model as providing a far better account of the observed results. Evidence is also provided that participants do not rely on all-or-none rote memories for the stored exemplars but rather use remembered exemplars as a basis for generalizing to novel transfer items from the learned categories. Limitations and directions of future work are discussed. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved)

Linguistics Perspective of Prototype Category

Prototype-based Category Theory and Its Application English Lexical Teaching in the English Lexical Teaching

Prototype Theory and Cognitive Pragmatics

A Random Set and Prototype Theory Model of Linguistic Query Evaluation

Context and the Plasticity of Prototypes

Relating Prototype Theory and Label Semantics

On the Translation of Terms in Civil Engineering from the Perspective of Prototype Categorization Theory

A Cognitive Analysis of Common Categories' Fuzziness

Application of prototype theory in Japanese intensive teaching

Vocabulary Teaching in English Polysemous Words Based on Prototype Category Theory

A Study on Second Language Vocabulary Acquisition Under the Categorization Theory

Linguistic modelling and information coarsening based on prototype theory and label semantics

Contrasting exemplar and prototype models in a natural-science category domain.

Human Cognitive Categorization and English Teaching

A Prototype Study of Progressive Aspect of English Verbs

A category theory perspective on the Language of Thought: LoT is universal

Linguistic Study in Philosophy Perspective

Prototype theory and the importance of literary form for moral imagination

Learning from Exemplars and Prototypes in Machine Learning and Psychology

Prototype or Exemplar Representations in the 5/5 Category Learning Task

The role of category valence in prototype preference