An Economic Analysis on the Scope of Administrative Compensation
JIN Wei-feng,JIANG Yu-fu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2006.02.016
2006-01-01
Abstract:The principle that property collection and expropriation must be given compensation has been validated by the Chinese constitution.However,some concrete problems such as the range and degree of compensation are yet to resolve.Legal analysis,which undoubtedly can prove its legitimacy,cannot perfectly testify the rationality of collection and expropriation.As a means of restricting private property rights in the interest of the public,people's loss resulting from collection and expropriation is just the one which should be given compensation.Economic analysis has its particular advantages in calculating loss and other interrelated problems.Economists classify goods into private goods,public goods,and semi-public goods which have characteristics both of private and public ones.In the market economy,production and consumption of public and semi-public goods cannot be realized effectively.This situation provides a good reason for government intervention into market.In order to maximize public interests,administrative agencies restrict people's private property by means of collection and expropriation.Hence,it should take responsibility for people's loss.In the present society,property rights are not only one kind of rights,they also shoulder corresponding social responsibilities in order to meet public interest,which is at the same time the cost of exerting rights.Once such social responsibilities exceed ordinary limit,sacrifices of property will result.If not properly compensated,it will lead to social injustice.Typical cases include the expropriation of property,the special restriction on the exertion of property rights and the deriving effect of administrative action.The range of administrative compensation also relates to the degree of compensation,which involves the standard of compensation.Relative to ″the wholly indemnity principle″ of civil indemnity and ″the impartial and rational indemnity principle″ of administrative indemnity,the administrative compensation must follow the ″justice principle″.When calculating the specific amount,consideration should be given to relative variables.In determining the standard of administrative compensation,attention must be paid to both public and the private interest.Decision-making must take the cost(private and social cost) and the benefit(private and social benefit) of administrative action into account,which calls for administrative agencies to internalize the cost of public interest.Administrative compensation must therefore include the realistic loss and the direct property loss related to the realistic one.