An Analysis of Loyalty Agreement from the Perspective of Natural Obligation

Xinyong CHEN,Fengdan SHEN
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-2714.2014.04.008
2014-01-01
Abstract:The validity of loyalty agreement is controversial and courts in different regions have different viewpoints on this issue . Some courts make judgments to support the agreement but others dismiss the cases or overrule the claims .Whether it is valid or not, supportive or not , if the validity of loyalty agreement is limited to legal obligation in our discussion , a loyalty agreement will have no legal basis and thus can't be acted through judicial channels .The way to overcome this dilemma is to see loyalty from the perspective of natural obligation which will also meet the needs for legal reason .A loyalty agreement can neither produce contrac-tual obligation according to contract law nor produce legal obligation such as nominate identity protocol according to marriage law . A loyalty agreement can only lead to natural obligation .In consideration of judicial humility on family affairs ,the courts should re-strain themselves and it's better to exclude the disputes of loyalty agreement from jurisdiction .
What problem does this paper attempt to address?