The affirmative inclination of the shì-bù-shì + VP question and its typological significance

邵敬敏,朱彦
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1002-5804.2002.03.003
2002-01-01
Abstract:It is found in this paper that the shi-bu-shi + VP question, different from other affirmative-negative questions, has, semantically, obvious affirmative inclination. A comparison between the shi-bu-shi + VP question and other affirmative-negative question, and the yes-no question with ba at the end in the degree of doubt shows that the shi-bu-shi + VP question is one that is consultative in nature. An analysis was made to find the pragmatic categories of this formula and the differences in the degree of doubt of the subcategories. Finally we made a chronological investigation of this formula and concluded it has a twofold origin: the contraction of shi + VP+ bu-shi and the transposition of VP +shi-bu-shi. The reason for this development lies in the fact that this formula is cognitively superior to the original ones, or probably in the influence of the dialectical formula V + bu + VO in the South. This phenomenon is significant in linguistic typology.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?