Abstract:In genetic association studies, detecting disease-genotype associations is a primary goal. For most diseases, the underlying genetic model is unknown, and we study seven robust test statistics for monotone association. For a given test statistic, there are many ways to calculate a p-value, but in genetic association studies, calculations have predominantly been based on asymptotic approximations or on simulated permutations. We show that when the number of permutations tends to infinity, the permutation p-value approaches the exact conditional enumeration p-value, and further that calculating the latter p-value is much more efficient than performing simulated permutations. We then answer two research questions. (i) Which of the test statistics under study are the most powerful for monotone genetic models? (ii) Based on test size, power, and computational considerations, should asymptotic approximations or exact conditional enumeration be used for calculating p-values? We have studied case-control sample sizes with 500-5000 cases and 500-15000 controls, and significance levels from 5e-8 to 0.05, thus our results are applicable to genetic association studies with only one genetic marker under study, intermediate follow-up studies, and genome wide association studies. We find that if all monotone genetic models are of interest, the best performance is achieved for a test statistics based on the maximum over a range of Cochrane-Armitage trend tests with different scores and for a constrained likelihood ratio test. For significance levels below 0.05, asymptotic approximations may give a test size up to 20 times the nominal level, and should therefore be used with caution. Further, calculating p-values based on exact conditional enumeration is a powerful, valid and computationally feasible approach, and we advocate its use in genetic association studies.

Association analysis of rare variants with quantitative trait based on minimum P-value

Pooled Association Tests for Rare Genetic Variants: A Review and Some New Results

[Family-Based Association Tests for Rare Variants].

ACAT: A Fast and Powerful P-value Combination Method for Rare-variant Analysis in Sequencing Studies

Testing Genetic Association with Rare Variants in Admixed Populations.

Identifying rare variants using a Bayesian regression approach

A Robust Model-free Approach for Rare Variants Association Studies Incorporating Gene-Gene and Gene-Environmental Interactions

Adjustment of Familial Relatedness in Association Test for Rare Variants

Block-based Association Tests for Rare Variants Using Kullback–Leibler Divergence

Powerful Rare‐Variant Association Analysis of Secondary Phenotypes

Protection switching and local area network emulation in passive optical networks

Rare variant association tests for ancestry-matched case-control data based on conditional logistic regression

Revisiting the genome-wide significance threshold for common variant GWAS

Population structure analysis using rare and common functional variants

Beyond guilty by association at scale: searching for causal variants on the basis of genome-wide summary statistics

Evaluating rare variants under two-stage design

Blindly using Wald's test can miss rare disease-causal variants in case-control association studies.

A Robust and Powerful Set-Valued Approach to Rare Variant Association Analyses of Secondary Traits in Case-Control Sequencing Studies.

Robust Methods for Disease-Genotype Association in Genetic Association Studies: Calculate P-values Using Exact Conditional Enumeration instead of Asymptotic Approximations

A Robust Statistical Method For Association-Based Eqtl Analysis

Deviation from baseline mutation burden provides powerful and robust rare-variants association test for complex diseases