[Comparison of the Performance of Three Prehospital Trauma Scores in Evaluation of Injury Severity among Lushan Earthquake Victims].
Yarong He,Hai Hu,Yaowen Jiang,Junfei Hu,Xiaohui Li,Yuanchang Yao,Dan Zhu,Bofu Liu,Liyuan Peng,Jianqing Wang,Yu Cao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.2095-4352.2014.08.012
2014-01-01
Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To investigate the performance of revised trauma score (RTS), CRAMS score (circulation, respiration, abdomen, motor and speech) and prehospital index (PHI) on evaluation of injury severity in earthquake victims.METHODS:Data of victims admitted to West China Hospital of Sichuan University during the Lushan earthquake from April 20th, 2013, to April 27th were retrospectively analyzed. The clinical information at admission was recorded, and the injury severity score (ISS), RTS, CRAMS and PHI were calculated. The optimal cut-off values were looked for, the comparability between the three scores and ISS score were figured out by receiver operator characteristic curve (ROC curve), and the correlation between ISS and three scores was analyzed by linear regression analysis.RESULTS:There was a total of 263 victims included in the study. ISS ≥ 16 was found in 86 cases, and ISS<16 in 177 victims, and there were significant statistic differences in male ratio (67.4% vs. 50.8%, χ² = 6.477, P=0.011), RTS score [7.55 (0.29) vs. 7.84 (0), U=6 825, P=0.013] and CRAMS scores [8 (1) vs. 9 (1), U=3 977, P=0.000] between two groups. It was showed by ROC curve analysis that the area under the ROC curve (AUC) of RTS, CRAMS and PHI was 0.547 (P=0.220), 0.734 (P=0.000) and 0.544 (P=0.250), and the Youden indexes of the three scores were 0.093, 0.443, and 0.119, respectively. Moreover, the best cut-off values of them were 4.9, 9.5 and 3.5. Linear regression analysis showed that RTS and CRAMS score showed negative correlation with ISS score (r₁=-0.139, P₁=0.024; r₂=-0.413, P₂=0.000), while PHI showed no relationship with it (r=0.071, P=0.250).CONCLUSIONS:Of these three scoring systems, CRAMS has the best correlation with ISS, and it can be used in the prompt assessment of trauma severity in earthquake victims.