A prospective randomized controlled multicenter clinical study comparing HOLTUR and TURis in patients with non-muscle invasive bladder cancer
姜帅,黄中力,牛远杰,郭剑明,林宗明,孙立安,王坤杰,刘春雨,徐志兵
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1000-6702.2016.07.005
2016-01-01
Abstract:Objective Compare the efficacy and safety of transurethral holmium laser resection of non-muscle invasive bladder tumor (HOLTUR) with transurethral resection in saline (TURis) method.Method From April 2010 to December 2014,in urology department of three different comprehensive medical center 120 cases of non-muscle invasive bladder cancer patients (111 male,9 female) were admitted;aged from 36 to 75 years old.The patients were randomized divided into two groups:holmium laser resection(HOLTUR) group (60 cases) and bipolar transurethral resection in saline (TURis) group (60 cases).HOLTUR group included 56 male and 4 female patients.In HOLTUR group 45 patients had single tumor in bladder,15 patients had multiple tumors (2-4) in bladder;Tumor location:left and right wall 40cases(66.7％),anterior wall 5 cases(8.3％),posterior wall 8 cases(13.3％),trigone 4 cases(6.7％),bladder neck 3 cases (5.0％).TURis group included 55 male and 5 female patients.In TURis group 42 patients had single tumor in bladder,18 patients had multiple tumors (2-4) in bladder (P =0.888).Tumor location:left and right wall 38 cases (63.3％),anterior wall 3 cases (5.0％),posterior wall 10 cases (16.7％),trigone 4 cases (6.7％),Neck 5 cases (8.3％).There is no statistical difference between 2 groups(P ＞ 0.05).The surgery method:①HOLTUR change the holmium laser rate to 16Hz,energy to 1 J.The bladder was examined with Olympus cystoscopy to confirm the tumor size and location.The holmium laser was used to resect the tumor 1 cm far from the tumor edge and its base to the bladder deep muscle.We also used holmium laser for hemostasis.For little bladder tumor we used holmium laser to vaporize the tumor directly after biopsy.②TURis:We use the olympus bipolar resectoscope to examine the bladder and confirm the location and size of tumor.Then we resected the tumor piece by piece until the deep muscle of bladder.And we used the TURis for hemostasis.The perioperative data of two groups were collected and compared.Perioperative data included the operation time,the obturator reflex incidence,bladder perforation incidence,catheterization time,postoperative hospital stay,tumor recurrence rate 3 months after surgery.Results All of the surgery were successful done.There were statistical difference (P ＜ 0.05 =between the operation time of two groups (22.6 ± 2.4) mins (HOLTUR group) vs.(33.3 ± 13.8) mins (TURis group),the obturator reflex incidence 0 (HOLTUR group) vs.43.3％ (TURis group),the perforation rate of bladder 0 (HOLTUR group) vs.10.0％ (TURis group).In HOLTUR group 54 patients had low grade bladder tumor,6 patients had high grade tumor,among whom one patient had carcinoma in situ(CIS).In TURis group 53 patients had low grade bladder tumor,7 patients had high grade tumor,among whom 2 patients had CIS.There was no statistical difference between two groups(P =1.000).According to 2014 CUA Guideline of non-muscle invasive bladder tumor,in HOLTUR group there were 21 patients with low risk,31 patients with middle risk and 8 high risk patients.In TURis group there were 23 patients with low risk,28 patients with middle risk and 9 patients with high risk.There were no statistical difference in tumor stage between two groups (P =1.000).There were no significant difference (P ＞ 0.05) of urinary catheter retention time (1.7 ± 0.2) days vs.(1.6 ± 0.2) days,(P =0.666),postoperative hospital stay (3.4 ± 0.3) days vs.(3.9 ± 0.2) days,(P =0.150)and recurrence rate 3 months after surgery(5/60 vs.7/60,P =0.762) between HOLTUR and TURis group.Conclusions Compared with TURis,transurethral holmium laser resection of non-muscle invasive bladder cancer has shorter operation time,no obturator nerve reflex,and less complications.It is a safe and reliable methods for the bladder tumor.