The preliminary comparative study between MRI and arthroscopy manifestation for rotator cuff injury
LIU Jia-chao,CHEN Jian-hai,HUANG Wei,WANG Tian-bing,JIANG Bao-guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2013.01.008
2013-01-01
Abstract:Background Rotator cuff,a sleeve-like structure composed of supraspinatus, infraspinatus muscle,teres minor and subscapularis,is the major anatomical structure to maintain shoulder stability. Rotator cuff pathologies are frequently encountered in patients with pain at the shoulder. The rotator cuff can be visualized with different imaging techniques such as ultrasonography( US),arthrography, arthroscopy,computed tomography( CT) and magnetic resonance imaging( MRI). MRI had quickly become the favored method for preoperative diagnosis of the rotator cuff injury,with high soft tissue resolution ratio, sensitivity and accuracy. It is clinically significant to correctly understand the MRI manifestation of patients with the painful shoulder. We retrospectively analyzed the MRI examination and arthroscopy findings of 59 rotator cuff injuries treated in one hospital. Methods( 1) Subjects: From July 2007 to December 2010,a total of 59 patients( 25 males and 34 females,aged from 24 to 83 years old,mean age 54. 33 years),who underwent arthroscopic surgery for their shoulder joint diseases,were selected. All the patients had shouder MRI examination before operation,we compared their preoperative MRI results with surgical findings.( 2) Arthroscopic surgery: All arthroscopic surgical procedures were performed by experienced directors or deputy directors of physicians to obtain an accurate diagnosis of the rotator cuff injury. All patients were treated by Stryker( Stryker) arthroscopic systems for their diagnosis and treatment. Diagnosis was based on the surgical records or video records.( 3) Magnetic resonance imaging: Multi-planar MR imaging of the shoulder was performed using coronal oblique,sagittal oblique and axial sequences. All MRIs were reported by a radiologist with special trained in musculoskeletal imaging.( 4) Diagnosis of rotator cuff injury: Based on the lannotti classification criterion,according to their pathological changes,rotator cuff injuries can be classified as ① Tendinitis: increased tendon signal intensity,no morphological changes,and intact shoulder-deltoid bursa fat layer. ② Partial-thickness tear: the increased limitations of signal intensity at the tendon, morphological changes accompanied by the discontinuity of the shoulder-deltoid bursa fat layer. ③ Full thickness tear: the significantly increased tendon signal intensity,obvious morphological abnormalities such as discontinuity of the tendon,tendon-muscle belly retraction or obvious muscle atrophy,ie the increased signal intensity of the muscles,the discontinuity or disappearance of the acromion-the deltoid bursa fat layer. Results Thirty-six out of 59 cases were diagnosed as the rotator cuff injury by MRI before operation,35 of which had been confirmed with tendinitis,partial-thickness tear or full thickness tear by arthroscopy during operation. One rotator cuff injury diagnosed before operation was proved to be intact arthroscopically. Seven cases with negative findings under MRI examination had been found to be rotator cuff injuries by arthroscopy. 16 cases( including fractures,shoulder instability or Bankart injury) of them presented intact in both MRI examination and arthroscopy operation. The sensitivity level of MRI examination for the rotator cuff injuries was 83. 3%. The specificity level of MRI examination was 94. 1%. The accuracy was 86. 4%. The degree of positive prediction was 97. 2%,and that of negative prediction was 69. 6%. These rotator cuff injuries included 3 cases of tendinitis,13 cases of partial-thickness tear( 10 of bursa side and 3 of articular side) and 22 cases of full-thickness tear. Discussion Patients with rotator cuff injury are frequently encountered. As a hub of upper limb activities,rotator cuff determines the range of the shoulder activitivy and space accuracy. The rotator cuff muscles are main strength source of the shoulder,which play a vital role in the shoulder function. Therefore,rotator cuff injuries at the shoulder would produce different degrees of dysfunction and painfulness,and seriously affect the patient' s quality of life and activities of daily living. Firstly,we need to define that the rotator cuff injury is a partial-thickness tear or a full-thickness tear. Ellman divided the partial-thickness rotator cuff tears into three categories: synovial side partial-thickness tear,intra-tendon partial-thickness tear and articular side partial-thickness tear. Each category is divided into three degrees according to the depth of tear: degree Ⅰ( < 3 mm),degree Ⅱ( 3-6 mm),degrees Ⅲ( > 6 mm),or more than 50% of the full-thickness at the tendon. Full-thickness tear classification is generally based on the size of tear: small tear( < 1 cm),medium tear( 1-3 cm),large tear( 3-5 cm) and a massive tear( > 5 cm). The imaging examination on the shoulder is indispensable in the diagnosis and classification of rotator cuff injuries,in addition to their detailed medical history and physical examination. The non- invasive and non-radioactive MRI, with excellent anatomy repeatability and organizational control comparability,can provide multi-angle,multi-plane and multi-level scan imaging,presenting a variety of normal and abnormal tissue structure imaging,which seems to be very important for the diagnose of shoulder diseases. In our study,the sensitivity level of MRI in diagnosis of the rotator cuff injury is 83. 3%. Seven cases which were negatively diagnosed in MRI examination had been proved to be rotator cuff injuries by arthroscopy. Using arthroscopy,we can observe the rotator cuff directly to identify the scope,size,and shape of tears. And the shoulder joint synovitis,supraspinatus tendon degeneration and partial tears of the biceps tendon and other pathological changes can be also determined by arthroscopy,which can' t be comparable with other imaging techniques. Therefore,it is necessary to use arthroscopy for the patients who have long- term shoulder pain,functional limitation,long-term conservative treatment fails and other tests difficult to diagnose. Arthroscopy can provide not only the confirmation of the diagnosis,but also the treatment such as debridement of the shoulder joint synovial tissue and calcification of supraspinatus tendon and suture of the teared rotator cuff. Conclusions According to our research and literature,generally speaking,MRI examination plays an important role for the diagnosis of rotator cuff injuries,which can provide the accurate determination of the extent,size and scope of rotator cuff injuries,as well as the signs associated. MRI can facilitate the development of treatment programs for the rotator cuff injuries,and eventually help patients to get timely and correct treatment.