Safety and Efficacy of Cryothermal and Radiofrequency Catheter Ablation in Treatment of Typical Atrial Flutter.
Wang Fang,Huang Cong-xin,Chen Gang,Zhang Feng,Meng Wei-dong,Sun Bao-gui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00029330-200706010-00012
2007-01-01
Abstract:Radiofrequency (RF) ablation of the critical isthmus between the tricuspid annulus and the inferior vena cava is commonly used to treat typical atrial flutter (AFL).1 This has become the first line therapy in Europe and in the US due to its high success rate and significant improvement in quality of life compared with conventional medical therapy.2 Sizeable lesions are required to achieve persistent bidirectional conduction block (BCB), which is the best endpoint to ensure long-term success.3,4 Cooling the ablation electrode by irrigation has been shown to prevent both overheating of the electrode-tissue interface and impedance rise during RF delivery, allowing greater power delivery and larger, deeper lesion.5 Recent studies showed that pain-free cryoablation was comparable to RF ablation regarding the short and long-term clinical success rate and safety.6 However, no studies have shown that cryoablation is superior to the irrigation RF ablation. In this study, we compared the efficacy and safety of cryoablation with the irrigation radiofrequency ablation technologies for typical AFL. METHODS Patients Eighteen consecutive patients with documented symptomatic common AFL (mean age (59.6±10.2) (54 - 77) years) were screened for the study. Inclusion criteria were as follows: history of episode of symptomatic typical AFL; demonstration by endocardial recordings of counter clockwise isthmus- dependent AFL or conduction through the cavotricuspid isthmus (CTI) by activation mapping during stimulation in the coronary sinus (CS) and right atrium during sinus rhythm. The patients were randomly assigned to two different ablation groups either with cryocatheter (8F 8-mm-tip, Freezor MAX catheter, CryoCath Technologies Inc., Kirkland, Canada) or saline-irrigated RF catheter (8F, 4 mm-tip catheters IBI, Cool Path™ 30W, 50°C). The protocol was approved by the hospital ethics committee. Informed consent was obtained from all patients. Of the 18 patients, 15 (83%) had structural heart disease, including hypertension (n=8), congestive heart failure (n=3), degenerative heart disease (n=4). All the patients had been known to have symptomatic AFL for a mean of (3.6±1.8) years and all failed in antiarrhythmic drug therapy. Three patients with persistent AFL developed congestive heart failure presumed to be related to tachycardia-induced cardiomyopathy. Left ventricular ejection fraction and left atrial size were measured before the procedure with 2-D echocardiography. Demographic characteristics of all patients are shown in Table 1.Table 1: Study population characteristicsAtrial flutter mapping and ablation The patients were studied in a fasting, nonsedated state. Vascular access was obtained via the right femoral vein by insertion of 8 Fr and 7 Fr sheaths. One 7 Fr duodecapolar Hallo catheter (2–10 mm interelectrode spacing) was advanced into the right atrium and positioned around the tricuspid annulus for sequential activation mapping to demonstrate clockwise/counterclockwise activation around the tricuspid annulus and through the isthmus. Additionally, concealed entrainment during pacing in the inferior CTI confirmed the isthmus-dependence of the arrhythmia. During sinus rhythm, pacing at inferior-septal and inferior-lateral sites was performed to verify conduction through the CTI by activation mapping. Stimulation from the CS ostium was performed to demonstrate conduction through the CTI in patients with sinus rhythm.7 The patients received repeated electrophysiological test after 30 minutes of observation to ensure BCB in CTI before the end of the procedure. Recurrence of conduction in CTI required repeated ablation. Those with a spontananeous flutter or induced flutter were considered acute recurrence. For cryoablation, a steerable 8 Fr, 8-mm-tip quadripolar cryocatheter (66 mm curve) was used with 2-mm spacing between distal and proximal electrodes, respectively (Freezor® MAX, CryoCath Technologies Inc., Montreal., Canada).8 Ablation was performed at a target temperature of -80°C, 4 minutes during sinus rhythm or AFL. For the cooled-tip catheter RF ablation, up to 50 W of RF energy were delivered. At each point ablation was performed at a target temperature of 50°C for 60 seconds. Saline (0.9%) was infused through the irrigated-tip catheter with a Gemini Imed pump (battery- powered to avoid 50-Hz line noise) at a rate of 17 ml/min during RF delivery. Between energy application, a flow rate of 3 ml/min was used to maintain patency. Follow-up The median follow-up period was 22 months (6 - 49 months). Patients were followed up in our hospital clinic after the ablation, especially those complained of discomfort. EKG or Holter recording was conducted after the procedures. Patients with recurrent AFL were advised to have repeat ablation. Statistical analysis Quantititive data were expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SD). To compare differences between two groups, student's t test was used for continuous variables, while Fisher's exact test was used for discrete variables. The follow-up time was expressed as median. A P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS After randomization, 9 patients were assigned to the RF ablation group, and 9 to the cryoablation group. There were no significant differences in sex ratio, age, weight, or structural heart disease between the two groups (Table 1). As shown in Table 2, the acute success rate for achieving bidirectional block over the CTI was 100% in all 18 patients based on the activation sequence on the duodecapolar catheter recording from lower lateral and low septal pacing. However, there was a high recurrence of trans-isthmus conduction during the initial success of bidirectional conduction block from the cryoablation group (14%). After additional cryoablation for these patients, the persistent bidirectional block was achieved in all patients in this group. Although there was no acute recurrence of trans-isthmus condution for the RF ablation group, there was one recurrence of AFL during the long-term followup (1 out 9 patients). There was no difference in mean fluoroscopy time between irrigated-tip catheter group ((18.0±11.9) minutes) and cryoablation group ((12.4±2.3) minutes; P>0.05). No patients reported episode of pain during cryoapplication, as compared to all patients who did with saline-irrigated catheter (P< 0.05). No procedural complications were observed with either technique.Table 2: Comparison of different catheter ablation technologies for typical flutterDISCUSSION Typical AFL is associated with reentry involving the critical isthmus bounded by the tricuspid valve annulus, the inferior vena caval orifice, the Eustachian ridge, and the ostium of coronary sinus. AFL could be eliminated by RF ablation of the isthmus by creating bi-directional blockage.1–9 In spite of acute success of bidirecrional conduction block over the CTI, the recurrence rate of isthmus-depdent AFL is still around 9%.10 One of the major reasons for this is the very thick isthmus, which prevents the complete transmural ablation. Saline-irrigated catheter with higher power and longer time of energy delivery allows deeper lesion.9 However, this may increase the risk of complications including discomfort and more severely, cardiac tamponade. Recently, catheter-based cryothermal ablation was introduced to treat cardiac arrhythmias.10 Cryoablation has been shown to produce much less discomfort and preserve the structure of the ablated tissue, thus decrease the risk of cardiac perforation. However there are reports of high recurrence rate with cryoablation for AVNRT,11 raising the concerns for its effctiveness. Recently high acute and long-term success rate for ablation of isthmus-dependent AFL was reported with cryoablation.5,6,12,13 Our present study confirms that the long-term success rate with cryoablation for CTI-dependent AFL is as high as that with the large tip saline irrigated RF ablation. With acute success of bidirectional conduction block, we observed no reuccrnece of AFL with cryoablation in the long-term followup. Our data may in fact suggest that cryoablation is superior to irrigated-tip RF ablation with recurrence rate of 0% and 11% respectively. This difference may be related to the increased energy deliver capacity from the cryocatheter.14 More importantly, we clearly demonstrated the superiority of cryoablation over saline irrigated RF ablation for discomfort as no one experienced pain with cryoablation, a common problem with RF ablation. The proven excellent safety and the absence of pain during cryoablation may make the cryoablation a desirable technique not only for AFL, but also for other cardiac arrhythmia, especially for those originating in regions like the coronary sinus and atria. The present preliminary study has its limitations. First, it is a small single center study with a very small sample size and a single-arm design. To compare the safety and effectiveness of the two different ablation methods, a large multicenter randomized clinical trial is needed before cryoablation for AFL is recommended for wide clinical application. Second, as in most studies on the long-term outcome of AFL ablation, we did not confirm the persistent bidirectional CTI block during the long term follow-up. The recurrence was only based mainly on symptom recurrence. Acknowledgments: We are grateful to Dr. LI Jian-ming. Dr. LI Jian-ming acted as Guest Reviser for this paper. LI Jian-ming now works as Assistant Professor Cardiac Pacing and Electrophysiology, Medical Director, Veterans Affairs Medical Center at Minneapolis, USA.