Characteristics of Non-cited Papers in Ten Surgical Comprehensive Journals

李贺琼,张小为,傅贤波,杨玉英,宋玮
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-6604.2018.04.004
2018-01-01
Abstract:Objective To analyze the characteristics of non-cited papers in ten surgical comprehensive journals. Methods Ten surgical comprehensive periodicals indexed in"2016 edition of China Scientific and Technical Citation Reports"were selected. The non-cited papers published in 2011 were searched and downloaded from the CNKI database.The number of authors, first author affiliation,paper foundation, and article types and length were analyzed. Results The number of non-cited papers in the ten surgical comprehensive periodicals was 435, with non-cited rates being 7.0%-20.0%.The non-cited rate of Chinese Journal of Practical Surgery was the highest,whose impact factor was at the second place, while Chinese Journal of Minimally Invasive Surgery was the lowest.Articles having 2-5 co-authors had the maximum proportion(75.9%)of non-cited rate, while articles having only one author had the minimum proportion(8.5%).Concerning first author affiliations of non-cited papers,provincial/medical university affiliated hospitals accounted for 49.0%, followed by municipal/medical college affiliated hospitals,42.3%.Unfunded articles had the highest proportion in the 435 non-cited papers,up to 87.1%(379/435),and articles funded by national foundation accounted for 3.9%(17/435).The average length of 435 papers was 2.3 pages.Among the non-cited papers,clinical study accounted for 57.9%(252/435),followed by case report,accounting for 22.8%(99/435). Conclusions Non-cited rates of ten surgical comprehensive periodicals in 2011 has little relationship with their impact factors.Among non-cited papers,articles having 2-5 authors predominate, and most first authors are from provincial or municipal hospitals.Unfunded articles account for a majority of proportion, and article types are mainly clinical research and case report.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?