A Comparative Study with 2μm Continuous-wave Thulium Laser and Transurethral Resection on the Treatment of Non-Muscle Invasive Bladder Tumor
Xinru ZHANG,Baojun GU,Hong XIE,Zhangshun LIU,Xi ZHANG,Weidong ZHU
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-1420.2010.06.02
2010-01-01
Journal of Clinical Urology
Abstract:Objective:To evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of 2μm continuous-wave thulium laser for the treatment of non-muscle-invasive bladder tumor (NMIBT) by comparing the results of transurethral resection (TURBt). Methods:We reviewed 85 patients with NMIBT who treated in our hospital, 33 cases were treated by TURBt, and 52 patients were treated by 2μm continuous-wave thulium laser. Of 56 cases whose bladder tumor were first been detected, 24 cases were multiple tumor. Of 22 cases the tumor diameter was greater 2. 5 cm. After surgery ,every patient accepted regular intravesical chemical drug instillation, and repeated cystoscope examination every 3 months. The recurrence-free survival rate of two groupsoperative time, postoperative hospital stay, complications and recurrence rate were also been compared. Results:The average operation time of overall patients was 26. 59±11. 63 min (5-75) min, with 24. 33±10. 10 min in 2μm thulium laser group and 30. 15±13. 08 min in TURBt group respectively (P=0. 034). No intraoperative complication was reported in 2μm thulium laser group while vesical perforation in 1 patient was found in TURBt group. Postoperative complications in 2 patients were found in 2μm thulium laser group while 3 occurred in TURBt group. The overall complication rate between two groups was no statistics difference (P = 0. 126). The postoperative hospitalization time of each group was 3. 19±0. 93 days in 2μm thulium laser group and 3. 83±1. 82 days in TURBt group (P=0. 067). 21 patients' tumor recurred during 15. 45±8. 08 months followup (range 3-39 months). In 2μm thulium laser group, 0,4,5,1 recurrence cases were found in 3,6,9,12 moths, one year recurrence rate was 19. 23% postoperatively, while in TURBt group, 1,2,4,2 recurrence cases were detected respectively, recurrence rate was 27. 27%. No statistics difference was found by comparing with the recurrence-free rate of two groups (P = 0. 341). Conclusions:Comparing with traditional TURBt, treating NMIBT with 2μm thulium laser could greatly increased operation safety and operation tolerant ability of patients. Shorter operation time and postoperative hospitalization time could be achieved, but no better clinical efficacy found by using 2μm thulium laser to treat NMIBT, there are still some limitations.