Medium and long term research on the effects of two internal fixations on functions of shoulder joints in humeral shaft fracture
Jian Li,Guangwu Zhang,Kun Zhang,Pengfei Lyu,Tao Xue
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2015.03.007
2015-01-01
Abstract:Background The humeral shaft fracture is a common injury among upper limbs fractures.There have been documents reporting that the humeral shaft fracture occupy 3% among all fractures.The common operation methods include plate fixation and intramedullary nail fixation. Most scholars think that plate fixation is the golden criteria for comparing all kinds of fixations.And whether the intramedullary nail fixation can affect the shoulder joints functions are still controversial. This thesis has retrospective analysis on 39 patients who performed humeral plate fixation and intramedullary nail fixation in our hospital from January 2001 to September 2012,aiming at studying the effects of shoulder joints functions performed by two internal fixations .Methods General data:39 patients,25 males and 14 females aging 21-75 years old with the average age 43.9 years old were selected as the study subjects.Injury reasons:21 cases were due to falling down,9 cases were due to traffic accident injury,3 cases were due to high falling accident injury,2 cases were due to machine injury,2 cases were due to exercise injury,1 case was due to violence injury,1 case was pathological fracture.According to the AO types,5 cases were with A1 type,6 cases were with A2 type,1 1 cases were with A3 type,1 1 cases were with B1 type,4 cases were with B2 type,2 cases were with C1 type.Open fracture:2 cases were with Gustilo I type,2 cases were with II type,1 case was with IIIa type.The average time from being injured to operation was 1.2 days.Operation methods:All patients were given brachial plexus anesthesia or general anesthesia.1 7 cases in the plate fixation group adopted the incision from anterolateral side,2 cases adopted posterior side.The materials of internal fixation were ordinary plate,dynamic compression plate (DCP)or locking compression plate (LCP).The plate will be fixed according to the AO type principles.At least 3 to 4 screws should be used to the distal and proximal fractures for fixation.The intramedullary nail fixation group selected the Hungary Sanatmetal interlocking intramedullary nails which have proximal radian 1 1-13 degrees in the main nail,and 3 lock holes in the proximal points,2 lock holes in the distal points can achieve the interlocking.They were inserted in direct motion ways.The intramedullary nails which were inserted into the anteroposterior position were tightly attached to the furrow of the inner side of greater tuberosity,and the ones that were inserted into the side position were located to the axle wire located in humeral shaft.Post-operative treatment:(1)Movement rehabilitation:post-operative neck wrist belt immobilization.After operation,the patients should not burden any weights,and keep doing the active and passive movements including clock pendulum movements,forward flexion,outstretch, adduction,internal rotation practice.If the X-ray film indicates the nonunion of fracture,the patients should not burden any weights.(2)Post-operation follow-up visit and evaluation criteria:All patients were followed up after operation.The items included:(1)X-ray check.(2)adopted HSS and JOA evaluation systems to evaluate the shoulder joints symptoms and functions.The shoulder joint pain evaluation system adopted visual assessment simulation (VAS).The movement range measurement adopted the angle tester.(3)Statistically treatment:Apply PASW Statistics 18.0 statistical software to statistical analysis.Adopted Mann-Whitney rank sum test to decide the movement ranges,HSS and JOA evaluation of the plate fixation group and the intramedullary nail fixation group,and judge whether the VAS evaluation exist differences.P < 0.05 regarded the difference have statistically significance.Results The patients in the plate fixation group were followed up from 1-1 1 year,with an average of 7.3 years.Patients in the intramedullary nail fixation group were followed up from 1-10 year,and the average was 6 years.39 cases got fracture union,and the average fracture union time was 13.1 weeks (8-24 weeks).The difference between the plate group and intramedullary nail fixation group have no statistically significance in the parameters of shoulder joint function evaluation,pain degree and movement ranges.Conclusion The injury reasons for shoulder joint dysfunction in humeral shaft fracture need to be further investigated.The operation skills for intramedullary nail fixation in direct motion should be enhanced.The patients should attach importance to the fracture functional rehabilitation in early phase,especially those patients above 50 years old.It is necessary to have randomly comparison of the two fixations in large samples.