A Meta-analysis of the efficacy of laparoscopy versus adrenalectomy for patients with pheochromocytoma
WANG Wei,ZHANG Jie,ZHOU Xiao-guang,WANG Hao,XU Ming-wei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.1674-0785.2012.18.045
2012-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the effectiveness of laparoscopy versus adrenalectomy for patients with pheochromocytoma.Methods A systemic review was performed according to the Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions.We searched Pubmed,the Cochrane library,CNKI and Wanfang database to retrieve all the randomized controlled trials.The bibliographies of the included studies were searched,too.The duration of search was from the date of databases set upto March 2012.Three independent researchers evaluated the included studies using GRADE.The extracted data were analyzed by RevMan 5.1 and GRAED profiler.Results Nine retrospective case control studies involving 145 cases and 175 controls were included.Meta-analyses showed six outcomes of laparoscopy compared with adrenalectomy,there was statistical difference in the efficacy of laparoscopy for patients with pheochromocytoma,in terms of operation time[WMD=-37.10,95% CI(-54.23,-19.98),P<0.0001],blood lose during operation [WMD=-246.43,95% CI(-294.98,-197.87),P<0.0001],the number of patients with acute fluctuation in blood pressure and heart rate[WMD=-2.75,95% CI(-3.53,-1.96),P<0.00001],postoperative activity out of bed days[WMD=-2.75,95% CI(-3.53,-1.96),P<0.00001],postoperative hospital stay[WMD=-2.77,95% CI(-3.49,-2.05),P<0.00001],mean duration of gastrointestinal tract recover[WMD=-0.91,95% CI(-1.37,-0.46),P<0.0001],the laparoscopy team was better than adrenalectomy team.However,the nine outcomes were all of low quality in the GRADE system and weak recommendation.Conclusions In the treatment of patients with pheochromocytoma,peritoneal laparoscopic surgery is feasible and safe,with no increase in the operation risks compared with adrenalectomy.Due to the poor quality,limitations and no control of confounding factors of the included studies,a prudent choice was suggested;and more high-quality,large sample studies were needed.