Impact Of Glucose Level On Estimated Glomerular Filtration Rate In Diabetic Patients

Haibing Chen,Lei Zhang,Yuqian Bao,Weiping Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1001-7097.2010.04.004

2011-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the influence of blood glucose level on the estimated glomeruhr filtration rate(eGFR)by Cockcroft-Gault(CG)and Modification of Diet in Renal Disease(MDRD)formula in diabetic patients,and to explore the difference between CG and MDRD formula to estimate GFR in different levels of blood glucose in the diagnosis of moderate renal insufficiency.Methods A total of 1210 diabetic patients(650 males and 560 females)were enrolled in this study.HbAlc,Scr and isotopic GFR(iGFR)((99m)~ Tc-DTPA)were measured.CG and MDRD formula were used to estimate the GFR(eGFR_(CG),eGFR_(MDRD)).The patients were divided into normal GFR group[NGFR,n=589,iGFR≥90 ml·min~(-1)·(1.73 m~2)~(-1)],gently decreased GFR group[GGFR,n=470,60≤iGFR<90 ml·min~(-1)·(1.73 m~2)~(-1)],moderate and sever decreased GFR group[MGFR,n=151,30≤iGFR<60 ml·min~(-1)·(1.73 m~2)~(-1)]based on the K/DOQI suggestion. According to the quartile HbAlc level(7.1%,10.5%),patients were divided into four groups.Patients with HbAlc<7.1% were defined as well-controlled group,with HbAlc≥10.5% as poorly-controlled group.Spearman correlation,t test,Bland-Altman analysis and ROC curve were applied to investigate the bias and accuracy of formula,and the influence of blood glucose on eGFR.Results HbAlc was correlated with iGFR(r=0.17,P<0.01),eGFR_(CG)(r=0.22,P<0.01),eGFR_(MDRD)(r=0.29,P<0.01).The correlation between eGFR_(MDRD) and HbAlc was the strongest.eGFR_(MDRD) seemed to overestimate GFR.However,eGFR_(CG) seemed to underestimate GFR in well-controlled group.Bland-Altman analysis indicated that the bias of eGFR_(MDRD) with iGFR in poorly-controlled group was higher than that in well-controlled group.Compared with poorly-controlled group,the 15% and 30% accuracies of eGFR_(MDRD) in well-controlled group were significantly higher.There was no significant difference between poorly-controlled group and well-controlled group in eGFR_(CG).The bias of eGFR_(CG) with iGFR was significantly higher than that of eGFR_(MDRD) with iGFR.The area under ROC curve was significantly greater in eGFR_(MDRD) than that in eGFR_(CG)(P<0.05)in poorly-controlled group.Conclusions eGFR by MDRD and CG formula in diabetic patients may lead to discrepancies with GFR value,eGFR_(MDRD) overestimates the GFR value.MDRD equation is more accurate and robust in poorly-controlled diabetic patients with mederate renal insufficiency.