Retrospective analysis on the selection of surgical procedures for laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair
ZHANG Yun,LI Jianwen,CHEN Xin,ZHENG Minhua,JIANG Yu,WANG Mingliang,LU Aiguo,HU Weiguo,MAO Zhihai,DONG Feng,CAI Wei,ZHANG Zhuo,ZANG Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1007-9610.2013.03.008
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective To investigate the choice of approach to laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair(LIHR).Methods The clinical data of 2 056 consecutive patients(2 473 hernias) undergoing LIHR between Jan 2001 and Dec 2011 at our hospital was retrospectively analyzed.There were 1 005 TAPP in 871 cases,1 458 TEP in 1 175 cases and 10 IPOM in 10 cases.All procedures were performed by the same surgical team,and the selection of the techniques was based by the surgeons.The follow-up period ranged from 15-60 months(median 42 months).Results There was significant difference between TAPP and TEP with respect to sex,age,disease duration,history of lower abdominal surgery,hernia type and classification(P<0.05).TAPP was preferable procedure for female(P<0.001),younger patients(P=0.006),and those with longer disease duration(P <0.001) and with history of lower abdominal surgery(P <0.001).TAPP was used more frequently in type Ⅳ(81.4%),while less frequently in type Ⅰ(27.4%)、 type Ⅱ(29.2%) and type Ⅲ(44.3%).TAPP was much more used for femoral hernias(61.1%) and recurrent hernias(81.4%),but less for indirect hernias(41.6%),combined hernias(35.0%) and direct hernias(22.9%).TAPP was the prior procedure in the first 3 years of study,and TEP was more frequently later.IPOM was used in 10 cases all recurrent hernias.One conversion to Lichtenstein was done in TAPP,while no conversion in TEP.The mean operation time(P=0.021) and postoperative hospital stay(P<0.001) were in favor of TEP.No significant difference was found in visual analogue pain scale(P=0.173) and proportion of patients returning to usual activities between TAPP and TEP(P =0.479).The recurrence rate in TAPP and TEP were 0.3% and 0.2% respectively with no significant difference between them(P=0.693).The morbidity of TAPP and TEP were 9.3%,6.6%,