Abstract:Iterative reconstruction has become the standard for routine clinical PET imaging. However, iterative reconstruction is computationally expensive, especially for time-of-flight (TOF) data. Block-iterative algorithms such as ordered-subsets expectation maximization (OSEM) are commonly used to accelerate the reconstruction. There is a tradeoff between the number of subsets and reconstructed image quality. The objective of this work was to evaluate the effect of varying the number of OSEM subsets on lesion detection for general oncologic PET imaging. Methods: Experimental phantom data were taken from the Utah PET Lesion Detection Database, modeling whole-body oncologic (18)F-FDG PET imaging of a 92-kg patient. The experiment consisted of 24 scans over 4 d on a TOF PET/CT scanner, with up to 23 lesions (diameter, 6-16 mm) distributed throughout the thorax, abdomen, and pelvis. Images were reconstructed with maximum-likelihood expectation maximization (MLEM) and with OSEM using 2-84 subsets. The reconstructions were repeated both with and without TOF. Localization receiver-operating-characteristic (LROC) analysis was applied using the channelized nonprewhitened observer. The observer was first used to optimize the number of iterations and smoothing filter for each case that maximized lesion-detection performance for these data; this was done to ensure that fair comparisons were made with each test case operating near its optimal performance. The probability of correct localization and the area under the LROC curve were then analyzed as functions of the number of subsets to characterize the effect of OSEM on lesion-detection performance. Results: Compared with the baseline MLEM algorithm, lesion-detection performance with OSEM declined as the number of subsets increased. The decline was moderate out to about 12-14 subsets and then became progressively steeper as the number of subsets increased. Comparing TOF with non-TOF results, the magnitude of the performance drop was larger for TOF reconstructions. Conclusion: PET lesion-detection performance is degraded when OSEM is used with a large number of subsets. This loss of image quality can be controlled using a moderate number of subsets (e.g., 12-14 or fewer), retaining a large degree of acceleration while maintaining high image quality. The use of more aggressive subsetting can result in image quality degradations that offset the benefits of using TOF or longer scan times.

Study of ordered subsets expectation maximization (OS-EM) algorithm based on different subsets

THE SIMULATED STUDY OF VARIABLE CONSTRAINT ORDERED SUBSETS EXPECTATION MAXIMIZATION (VCOSEM)

Comparison study on typical reconstruction algorithms for fan-beam geometric SPECT

An improved ordered subsets expectation maximization reconstruction

An Improved Ordered Subsets Expectation Maximization Positron Emission Computerized Tomography Reconstruction

Ordered Subset Expectation Maximization Algorithm for Positron Emission Tomographic Image Reconstruction Using Belief Kernels

OSEM Reconstruction with Overrelaxation

Effect of varying number of OSEM subsets on PET lesion detectability

EMISTA-Based Quantitative PET Reconstruction.

Study of OSEM with Different Subsets in Grating-Based X-ray Differential Phase-Contrast Imaging

Robust Framework for PET Image Reconstruction Incorporating System and Measurement Uncertainties.

Low Dose PET Image Reconstruction with Total Variation Using Alternating Direction Method.

Superiorization of EM Algorithm and Its Application in Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography(SPECT)

Evaluation of imaging protocol for ECT based on CS image reconstruction algorithm

Application of OSEM with Variable Overrelaxation in PET Reconstruction

Optimization of the Algorithm for the Implementation of Point Spread Function in the 3D-OSEM Reconstruction Algorithm Based on the List-Mode Micro PET Data

Uncertainty Penalized Weighted Least Squares Framework For Pet Reconstruction Under Uncertain System Models

Evaluation of the 3D IMF-OSEM Algorithm by Using Data from a High Resolution PET Scanner

Stochastic EM methods with Variance Reduction for Penalised PET Reconstructions

Step-and-shoot Dynamic Whole-body PET Parametric Imaging with Weighted Expectation Maximization Algorithm

The effect of different reconstruction algorithms on the image quality of SPECT Hoffmann phantom