Comparison of two HBV DNA detection kits
Hai-ying ZHANG,Ying JI,Ling ZHU,Hui-ying RAO,Jiang-hua WANG,Heng-hui ZHANG,Xing-wang XIE,Lai WEI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1009-9158.2011.05.017
2011-01-01
Abstract:Objective To evaluate clinical significance of two real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR kits for quantitative detection of HBV DNA and detection performance at different viral load levels.Methods A series of calibrators with different concentrations(1×106,5×105,1×105,5×104,1×104,5×103,1×103,5×102,1×102,1×101 kIU/L) were prepared with AB-type sera using the second generation WHO international standard (NIBSC code:97/750). HBV viral load in the sera of 78 patients,30 healthy blood donors and 10 calibrators were detected by real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR HBV DNA test kit from PIJI Bio-Technical Development Company Ltd (PG kit) and Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test kit. The correlation of the two methods was evaluated, and the performance of the two kits different viral load levels was evaluated. The false negative rate was analyzed. Negative control, low positive control and high positive control were included in every batch. Results Both two kits showed the correct results for the 10 specimens from the WHO international standards. The lowest detection limit of HBV DNA for Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test and PG kit were 2.00 (kIU/L, lg) and 3.00 (kIU/L,lg) ,respectively. There was linear correlation between the results from Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test and PG kit ( R2=0.938 7, P < 0.01 ), the upper limit of Roche kit had coincided with theoretical value. The samples with HBV DNA level above the upper limit of detection were diluted and retested to obtain the precise result. The result form Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cabas TaqMan HBV test [(8.35±0.20) kIU/L, lg] was higher than that from PG kit [(7.73±0.42 ) kIU/L, lg] (t=3. 776, P <0.05) . The detection of 108 serum samples showed that the level of HBV DNA detected by Roche Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test [(5.88±1.64) kIU/L, lg] was higher than that by PG kit [(5.25±1.55 kIU/L,lg] (t=12. 297 ,P <0.01 ). The correlation coefficients were high in samples with high HBV viral load[HBV DNA(>5.00 and≤7.00) kIU/L,Ig,R2=0. 779 7, P <0.01 ;HBV DNA( >7.00 ands≤9.00) kIU/L,lg,R2=0.603 7, P <0.01]. The correlation coefficient was low in samples with low HBV viral load[HBV DNA ( > 3.00 and≤5.00) kIU/L, lg, R2=0. 417 3, P <0.01 )]. When HBV DNA ( >3.00 and≤4.00) kIU/L,lg,the false negative rate was 33.3% (5/15). When HBV DNA ( > 1.08and≤3.00) kIU/L,lg,none of positive samples was detected with PG kit. Conclusions PG kit is not as good as Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test . The linear correlation between the results from the two kits is good. The correlation between the results detected with PG kit and Cobas AmpliPrep/Cobas TaqMan HBV test is higher in the high viral load groups than in the low viral load group. It is suggested that PG kit had a narrower linear range.