Comparision of magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasound in diagnosis of breast intraductal papilloma

Fei Xie,Bo Zhou,Shu Wang,Yingming Cao,Peng Liu,Fei Yuan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-4777.2016.02.034
2016-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the values of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ultrasonographic (US) in diagnosis of breast intraductal papilloma (IP).Methods The US and MRI data of 74 patients from February 2009 to April 2015 with IP were retrospectively analyzed.The detection rate and accuracy rate of US and MRI were compared.Results In 74 cases,the mass was observed in US in 47 cases;there were 34 (72.3%) of were hypoecho,7 (14.9%) of anechoic and 6 (12.8%) of mixed echo;there were 22 (46.8%) of circular shape,9 (19.1%) of lobulated shape and 16 (34.0%) of irregular shape;there were 29 (61.7%) with clear margin and 18 (38.3%) with unclear margin;there were 23 (48.9%) with posterior acoustic enhancement and 24 (51.10%) with no change.MRI found the mass in 60 cases;there were 44 (73.3%) of circular shape,7 (11.7%) of lobulated shape and 9 (15.0%) of irregular shape;there were 44 (73.3%) with clear margin,9 (15.0%) with irregular margin and 7 (11.7%) with spiculated margin;there were 53 (88.3%) with internal homogeneous enhancement,6 (10.0%) with internal heterogeneous enhancement and 1 (1.7%) with edge enhancement;there were 25 (41.7%) of type I time-signal intensity curve (TIC),22 (36.7%) of type Ⅱ TIC and 13 (21.7%) of type Ⅲ TIC.The detection rate of MRI and MRI combined with US was significantly higher than that of US [93.2% (69/74),100.0% (74/74) vs 66.2% (49/74)] (P <0.001);the accuracy rate of MRI and US was not significantly different [56.8% (42/74) and 43.2% (32/74)] (P =0.100),the accuracy rate of MRI combined with US [60.8 (45/74)] was significantly higher than that of US (P =0.032).Conclusion MRI has higher detection rate and similar accuracy rate compared with US in IP patients;detection rate and accuracy rate of MRI combined with US are both increased compared with single use of US.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?