Reviving Medicine As the Art of Humanity in China.
Joseph D Tucker,Jing-Bao Nie,Yu Cheng,Wei Zhu,Arthur Kleinman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0140-6736(14)60715-7
2014-01-01
Abstract:"Medicine is the art of humanity" (yi nai ren shu, in Chinese). Yet, the art of medicine in modern China is in profound disarray. Mistrust between patients and physicians has become endemic, and stories of patients killing the physicians entrusted to heal them are increasingly common.1The LancetEnding violence against doctors in China.Lancet. 2012; 379: 1764Scopus (82) Google Scholar A ten- province survey in China showed that more than half of physicians had been verbally abused, a third of physicians were threatened, and 3·4% were physically assaulted by patients.2Zhang X Sleeboom-Faulkner M Tensions between medical professionals and patients in mainland China.Camb Q Healthc Ethics. 2011; 20: 458-465Crossref PubMed Scopus (84) Google Scholar This widespread patient–physician mistrust has affected medical education in China. More than three-quarters of physicians in China would not advise their children to follow their footsteps into medicine.3Jiang NJ 70% of doctors would not want their children to be doctors.http://health.people.com.cn/GB/15471173.htmlDate: 2011Google Scholar At the same time, the medical education system importantly shapes the values of modern medicine and could be a fulcrum for change. Reforming preclinical and clinical education in China can help begin to rebuild patient–physician trust. First, enhancing of preclinical ethics, humanities, and social science training that directly relate to medicine could promote doctors' empathy for patients and crucial reflection skills that nurture professionalism.4Dossett ML Kohatsu W Nunley W et al.A medical student elective promoting humanism, communication skills, complementary and alternative medicine and physician self-care: an evaluation of the HEART program.Explore. 2013; 9: 292-298Summary Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (14) Google Scholar Many medical schools in China incorporate ethics in a symbolic manner, but expanding and firmly rooting these fundamental discussions in modern medical disputes would increase student engagement and clinical relevance. Second, clinical instruction to improve communication can provide medical students with a set of techniques to better manage disputes and navigate the health systems issues that underpin mistrust. These thorny topics are rife with tension and deserve increased attention as a core component of medical education. While such reforms can learn from effective programmes outside China, they can also draw on the rich ancient Chinese tradition of humanism in medicine exemplified by Sun Simiao's "the excellence and sincerity of the great physician".5Nie J-B Medical ethics in China: a transcultural interpretation. Routledge, London2011Google Scholar There are inevitably tradeoffs associated with expanding humanistic medical training. Increased humanism within medical education is necessary but not sufficient for ensuring patient–physician trust in China. A wide range of legal, social, and financial changes are also necessary. Present medical curricula are stretched taut and most schools do have enough full-time medical humanists. However, the Chinese crisis of patient–physician mistrust provides a powerful empirical clinical context by which to promote humanistic medical training. Humanistic training to deepen modern patient–physician trust could help revive and safeguard the old Chinese moral ideal of medicine as the art of humanity. We declare that we have no competing interests.