Abstract:To limit tail biting incidence, most pig producers in Europe tail dock their piglets. This is despite EU Council Directive 2008/120/EC banning routine tail docking and allowing it only as a last resort. The paper aims to understand what it takes to fulfil the intentions of the Directive by examining economic results of four management and housing scenarios, and by discussing their consequences for animal welfare in the light of legal and ethical considerations. The four scenarios compared are: 'Standard Docked', a conventional housing scenario with tail docking meeting the recommendations for Danish production (0.7 m2/pig); 'Standard Undocked', which is the same as 'Standard Docked' but with no tail docking, 'Efficient Undocked' and 'Enhanced Undocked', which have increased solid floor area (0.9 and 1.0 m2/pig, respectively) provision of loose manipulable materials (100 and 200 g/straw per pig per day) and no tail docking. A decision tree model based on data from Danish and Finnish pig production suggests that Standard Docked provides the highest economic gross margin with the least tail biting. Given our assumptions, Enhanced Undocked is the least economic, although Efficient Undocked is better economically and both result in a lower incidence of tail biting than Standard Undocked but higher than Standard Docked. For a pig, being bitten is worse for welfare (repeated pain, risk of infections) than being docked, but to compare welfare consequences at a farm level means considering the number of affected pigs. Because of the high levels of biting in Standard Undocked, it has on average inferior welfare to Standard Docked, whereas the comparison of Standard Docked and Enhanced (or Efficient) Undocked is more difficult. In Enhanced (or Efficient) Undocked, more pigs than in Standard Docked suffer from being tail bitten, whereas all the pigs avoid the acute pain of docking endured by the pigs in Standard Docked. We illustrate and discuss this ethical balance using numbers derived from the above-mentioned data. We discuss our results in the light of the EU Directive and its adoption and enforcement by Member States. Widespread use of tail docking seems to be accepted, mainly because the alternative steps that producers are required to take before resorting to it are not specified in detail. By tail docking, producers are acting in their own best interests. We suggest that for the practice of tail docking to be terminated in a way that benefits animal welfare, changes in the way pigs are housed and managed may first be required.

The Influence of the Feature of Environmental Enrichment and Tail Docking on Biting Behavior and Productivity in Weaned Piglets

Teeth Clipping, Tail Docking and Toy Enrichment Affect Physiological Indicators, Behaviour and Lesions of Weaned Pigs after Re-Location and Mixing

A High Enrichment Replenishment Rate Reduces Damaging Behaviors and Increases Growth Rate in Undocked Pigs Kept in Fully Slatted Pens

Effects of Zinc on Growth Performance and Biochemical Parameters of Piglets

Comparison of pig behaviour when given a sequence of enrichment objects or a chain continuously

Effects of Tail Docking And/or Teeth Clipping on Behavior, Lesions, and Physiological Indicators of Sows and Their Piglets

Effects of Tail Docking and Teeth Clipping on the Physiological Responses, Wounds, Behavior, Growth, and Backfat Depth of Pigs

Effect of Straw Enriched Environment on Behaviors of Nursery Piglets Reared in the Farrowing Pens.

Effects of Two Different Early Socialization Models on Social Behavior and Physiology of Suckling Piglets

Effect of Lactation Environment on Behaviour of Suckling Piglets

The Effects of Space Allowance and Toy Provision on the Growth, Spatiotemporal Distribution of Behavior, and Pen Cleanliness of Finishing Pigs

Research on Application of DL-RSM and Compound Enzymes in Fattening Pigs Diet

Effects of double-low rapeseed meal and complex enzymes on growth performance and serum indicators of finishing pigs

Effects of Weaning Modes on the Intestinal pH, Activity of Digestive Enzymes, and Intestinal Morphology of Piglets

Effect of Environment on the Productivity and Physiological Indicator of Nursery Piglets

Impact of Early Socialization Environment on Social Behavior, Physiology and Growth Performance of Weaned Piglets

Effect of enriched environmental on performance, carcass traits and meat quality of finishing pigs

Equipping Farrowing Pens with Straw Improves Maternal Behavior and Physiology of Min-Pig Hybrid Sows

Effects of Enzyme Additives in Wheat- and Double Low Rapeseed Meal- Based Diets on Performance of Growing-finishing Pigs

Why are most EU pigs tail docked? Economic and ethical analysis of four pig housing and management scenarios in the light of EU legislation and animal welfare outcomes

Effects of Environment and Breed on Growth Performance and Meat Quality of Fattening Pigs