Abstract:The current study reports three experiments to test whether and how unconscious activation of distractors with subliminal presentation, especially at stimulus level, affects response to targets in a letter flanker task. In each experiment, the flanker letters were made unconscious using visually backward masking letters. As classic Flanker tasks, the congruency between target letters and flankers were manipulated to form three conditions – conflicting at stimulus level, conflicting at response level, and non-conflicting. Stimulus conflict referred to trials in which the target and the flankers differed but linked to the same response key, indicating that the competition between the target and flankers occurs at stimulus level. In contrast, response conflict referred to trials where the target and flankers were not only different but also associated with distinct response keys, indicating that the competition between the target and flankers emerges at both the stimulus and response levels. Non-conflict referred to congruent target and flankers trials, used as a baseline condition. Accordingly, the stimulus conflict effect was the difference between stimulus conflict and non-conflict conditions, while the response conflict effect was the difference between response conflict and non-conflict condition. A total of fifty seven participants this study. Experiment 1A was a baseline experiment with supraliminal flankers, in which the classical effects of stimulus conflict and response conflict were observed. However, when the flankers were made unconscious in Experiment 1B using subliminal flankers, a reversed stimulus conflict effect emerged but the response conflict effect maintained. These results were replicated in Experiment 2 when symbolic stimuli were used to reduce the difficulty in forming a stimulus-response association. Likewise, the effects were observed in Experiment 3 with more stimuli and response types were introduced. Crucially, the effect of stimulus conflict dynamically varied along different time windows, while the effect of response conflict was stable across time windows. Altogether, the results provided systematically behavioral evidence for the subliminal activation of distractors that affects target performance at both the stimulus and response levels in a flanker task. The data indicated that the unconscious representation of distractors dynamically influences stimulus processing of targets over time but exerts a stable impact on responses. Our findings, especially the unconscious representation at stimulus level can clarify the mechanism and integrate previous contradicting conclusions of unconscious processing.

The Effect of Supraliminal and Subliminal Reward Information on Conscious and Unconscious Response Inhibition

Influence of Supraliminal Reward Information on Unconsciously Triggered Response Inhibition

Reward Enhances Backward Inhibition in Task Switching

Reward Modulates Unconsciously Triggered Adaptive Control Processes

Subliminal Reward Modulates the Tradeoff Between Proactive and Reactive Cognitive Control

Neural signature of reward-modulated unconscious inhibitory control

Enhanced intentional inhibition with increased subliminal action preparation

Reward Improves Response Inhibition by Enhancing Attentional Capture

Effects of Supra- and Sub-liminal Emotional Cues on Inhibition of Return

Two fundamentally different mechanisms by which unconscious information impairs behavioral performance: Evidence from fMRI and computational modeling

An Experimental Study On The Relationship Between Interference And Affective Priming

The enhancing effect of social reward on inhibitory control in smokers: Evidence from behaviour and ERP studies

Unconscious Reward Facilitates Motion Perceptual Learning

A Comparative Study Between Supraliminal and Subliminal Emotional Stroop Effects

The Effect of Response Inhibition Training on Risky Decision-Making Task Performance

Neurophysiological mechanisms underlying the differential effect of reward prospect on response selection and inhibition

The Influence of Reward Anticipation on Conflict Control in Children and Adolescents: Evidences from Hierarchical Drift-Diffusion Model and Event-Related Potentials

Reward produces learning of a consciously inaccessible feature

The Impact of Construal Level on Behavioral Inhibition: Evidences from Behavioral and ERP Studies

Existing Evidence and Controversy of Subliminal Persuasion

The stimulus representation of unconscious information and its temporal characteristics