Combination Rules for Multiple Coplanar Cracks Based on Fatigue Life

ZHAN Yong,WEN Jian-feng,TU Shan-tung,XUAN Fu-zhen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-4837.2016.02.001

2016-01-01

Abstract:The remnant fatigue lives of finite thickness plates containing a twin of semi-elliptical surface cracks under cyclic loadings are predicted by using finite element simulation technique in order to assess the conservatism of coalescence criteria in the existing structural integrity assessment standards.Twenty-two groups of crack configurations and two different material properties(304 stainless steel and 16MnR steel) are used in the analysis.The conservative degrees of three existing crack coalescence criteria and one type of combination rule presented by authors are discussed.Compared with the remnant lives ob-tained by the method considering interaction,the results show that the conservative degrees of the existing combination rules are highly dependent on the relative size of crack to wall thickness.Combination rules suggested by BS 7910 and ASME may lead to non-conservative results when initial crack depth is large.In addition,the rules suggested by A16,API 579-1 and GB/T 19624—2004 are over conservative.The paper proposes a new combination rule i.e.the minimum distance between cracks being equal to the average crack depth.By conducting sensitivity analysis of parameters in the formula for correlating crack growth rates,it is also found that the conservative degree of the combination rule is significantly dependent on the exponent n in Paris law but is marginally affected by the coefficient C.