Dynamic Heat Transfer on Skin Phantom Exposed to R404A Pulsed Spray Cooling
Yang Ran,Zhu Xingang,Yang Tao,Zhou Zhifu,Chen Bin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3788/cjl202249.0507105
2022-01-01
Chinese Journal of Lasers
Abstract:Objective Cryogen spray cooling (CSC) with several tens of milliseconds prior to laser irradiation has been widely used in laser surgeries for treating port-wine stain (PWS). CSC can protect the epidermis from nonirreversible thermal injuries due to competitive absorption by melanin in the epidermis; thus, enhancing the threshold of laser energy. However, the currently used cryogen R134a has shown little efficacy in protecting dark patients as compared with white patients because of the higher melanin content in the epidermis. Meanwhile, to improve the cooling capacity, R404A has been proposed to replace the R134a due to its lower boiling temperature, higher latent heat of vaporization, nontoxicity, and friendly with ozone depletion. In this paper, the influence of spray distance and the duration on the dynamic heat transfer of R404A spray cooling is quantitatively investigated through experiments to analyze the mechanism of heat transfer under different conditions. These results are useful in selecting optimal CSC parameters for PWS patients with dark skin, which are significant for the clinical applications of R404A spray cooling in laser dermatology. Methods This study developed an experimental system of CSC, which included the cryogen spray generation and surface transient temperature measurement parts (Fig. 1). The cryogen spray generation system consists of a high-pressure nitrogen bottle, cryogen container, fast-response solenoid valve, and straight-tube nozzle. The liquid cryogen R404A was stored in the cryogen container that connected with the high-pressure nitrogen bottle to adjust its pressure. A solenoid valve was used to precisely control the opening and closing of the pulsed spray, and the nozzle was fitted tightly into the outlet of the solenoid valve. The relative space between the nozzle tip and the measurement points on the cooling surface was controlled by a three-dimensional positioner. The measurement part consists of a fast-response film thermocouple and data acquisition system. The thin-film thermocouple (TFTC) with 2 mu m thickness was directly deposited on the skin phantom (epoxy resin) through the magnetron sputtering technique. The response time of TFTC is only 1. 2 mu s fast enough to capture the rapid change of surface temperature. A LabVIEW software system was used to control the temperature sampling, the start and close of the solenoid valve. Then, Duhamel's theorem was used to calculate the heat flux of the epoxy resin surface based on the measured surface temperature. The heat transfer coefficient was estimated using Newton' s law of cooling. The boiling curves on the cooling surface were also obtained based on the heat flux and surface temperature. Results and Discussions The effect of spray distance on the surface temperature depends on the duration scale. The minimum temperature T-min under short spray duration, such as 20 ms, increases as the spray distance increases. However, for a long spray duration, such as 100 ms, there exists an optimal spray distance of 30 mm that obtains the minimum temperature T-min (Fig. 2). As the spray distance decreases, the rate of surface temperature change increases, resulting in a higher maximum surface heat flux q(max) and higher maximum surface heat transfer coefficient h(max). Thus, the maximum heat flux q(max) and heat transfer coefficient h(max) decrease monotonously with the spray distance regardless of the spray duration (Figs. 3 and 4). Therefore, increasing the spray duration can only prolong the remaining time of the cryogen liquid film on the epoxy resin surface (Fig. 5). However, the maximum heat flux q max and maximum heat transfer coefficient h max hardly change (Figs. 6 and 7). The spray distance has more obvious influences on the surface heat transfer characteristics than the spray duration. The boiling curves of heat transfer of R404A pulse spray cooling under different conditions are quite similar (Fig. 8). A piecewise linear correlation of dimensionless heat flux has been proposed through theoretical analysis (Fig. 9). It demonstrates the similarity of dynamic heat transfer on epoxy resin exposed to R404A pulsed spray cooling. The entire cooling process can be separated into two stages: the impinging nucleate boiling and liquid film evaporation. Conclusions R404A can replace R134a due to its stronger cooling capacity in CSC. In this paper, the influence of spray distance and duration on the dynamic heat transfer of the R404A spray cooling is quantitatively investigated through experiments to analyze the mechanism of heat transfer under different conditions. The results show that increasing spray duration can prolong the cooling time of the liquid film; thus, improving the cooling protection of the skin. The maximum surface heat flux q(max) and maximum heat transfer coefficient h(max) decrease as the spray distance increases. It is worth noting that q(max) changes slightly before 30 mm. Thus, the distance of 30 mm may be regarded as the optimal spray distance that obtains the lowest minimum temperature and relatively high heat flux. Finally, the dimensionless heat flux correlation is proposed based on theoretical analysis.