Process difference and economy analysis between oil gasification and coal gasification

Zhen ZHANG,Guo-qiang ZHAO,Yi-ni ZHANG,Bin CHEN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1005-9954.2017.06.014

2017-01-01

Chemical engineering

Abstract:Based on GE gasification technology, this paper firstly gives a brief introduction to the features of coal water slurry gasification and oil gasification and their domestic application performance, and then makes a comparative analysis from the aspects of process flow, process configuration, main technical parameters, economic and others to elaborate the difference and advantage between coal gasification and oil gasification.This analysis provides the basis for the selection of raw materials and process configuration of gasification for the owners.The research shows that, compared to GE coal water slurry gasification, GE oil gasification has many advantage : the simpler process of feed storage and transportation system, the slag handing system and black water flash system, the longer service life of refractory brick, the longer continuous operation period of the gasifier, lower specific coal and oxygen consumption, higher effective gas content in raw gas, higher ratio of hydrogen to carbon, lower utility consumption, lower fixed asset investment.Besides, the unit production cost of coal water slurry gasification is more sensitive to the price of raw materials.