Abstract:The connected vehicle systems (CVS) aim to provide drivers with information in a timely and reliable way to improve transportation safety. With the emerging wireless communication technologies, the vehicles will be equipped with the ability to communicate with each other about the surrounding traffic situations by exchanging vehicle status and motion data via Dedicated Short-Range Communications (DSRC) network (Kenney, 2011). With the assistance of the cooperative collision warnings, the impact of designed warning parameters on driver performance is increasingly important. Existing empirical studies have studied the warning timing and warning reliability in determining the effectiveness of the collision warning systems in advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS). In terms of warning timing, the studies in reached consistent conclusions that early warnings induced more timely braking and longer braking process, resulted in higher trust of the warning systems, and reduced collision rates (for example, Abe & Richardson, 2006a; Lee, McGehee, Brown, & Reyes, 2002; Yan, Xue, Ma, & Xu, 2014; Yan, Zhang, & Ma, 2015; Wan, Wu, and Zhang, 2016). In terms of the warning reliability, research has shown that warnings with a higher reliability increased driver’s trust of the warning systems, led to higher frequency in warning responses, and reduced crash rates (for example, Abe, Itoh, & Yamamura, 2009; Bliss & Acton, 2003; Maltz & Shinar, 2007; Sullivan, Tsimhoni, & Bogard, 2008). However, the interaction effects of warning lead time and warning reliability on driver performance was not examined especially under the connected vehicle settings. The current research investigated the interaction effects of warning lead time (2.5s vs. 4.5s), warning reliability (73% vs. 89%), and speech warning style (command vs. notification) on driver performance and subjective evaluation of warnings in CVS. A driving simulator study with thirty-two participants was conducted to simulate a connected vehicle environment with missing warnings due to the failures in the data transmission within the communication network of the CVS. The results showed command warnings led to a smaller collision rate compared to notification warnings with the warning lead time of 2.5s, whereas notification warnings resulted in a smaller collision rate compared to command warning with the warning lead time of 4.5s. These results suggested notification warnings should be selected when warning lead time is longer and warning reliability is higher, which resulted in higher safety benefits and higher subjective ratings. Command warnings could be selected when warning lead time is shorter since they led to more safety benefits. However, such selection has to be made with caution since command warnings may limit drivers’ response type and were perceived as less helpful than notification warnings.

Warning Effectiveness of Vehicle-to-infrastructure Cooperative Crossing Collision Prevention System at Non-signal Controlled Intersection

Heterogeneity in the Effectiveness of Cooperative Crossing Collision Prevention Systems

Effects of collision warning characteristics on driving behaviors and safety in connected vehicle environments

Effect of Warning System on Interactive Driving Behavior at Unsignalized Intersection under Fog Conditions: A Study Based on Multiuser Driving Simulation

Research on the effectiveness of a intersection risk warning system based on driving simulation experiment

Investigating the Influence of Connected Information on Driver Behaviour: an Analysis of Pedestrian-Vehicle Conflicts in the Middle Section of Urban Road

Effect of Driving Experience on Collision Avoidance Braking: an Experimental Investigation and Computational Modelling

Effects of Warning Characteristics on Driver Performance in Connected Vehicle Systems with Missing Warnings

Changes of Drivers' Visual Performances when Approaching a Signalized Intersection under Different Collision Avoidance Warning Conditions

Drivers' Eye Movements As a Function of Collision Avoidance Warning Conditions in Red Light Running Scenarios.

The Effects of Warning Characteristics on Driver Behavior in Connected Vehicles Systems with Missed Warnings

The Influence of In-Vehicle Speech Warning Timing on Drivers' Collision Avoidance Performance at Signalized Intersections

Using a V2V- and V2I-based collision warning system to improve vehicle interaction at unsignalized intersections

Developing a New Omni-Directional Collision Warning System for Intelligent Vehicles

Investigation into the Effect of an Intersection Crash Warning System on Driving Performance in A Simulator

Exploring the Effects of Signs' Design and In-Vehicle Audio Warning on Driver Behavior at Flashing-Light-Controlled Grade Crossings: A Driving Simulator-Based Study

Evaluation of Cooperative Systems on Driver Behavior in Heavy Fog Condition Based on a Driving Simulator.

The Effect of Lead Time of Collision Warning Messages on Driver Performance

Driving-Simulator-Based Test on the Effectiveness of Auditory Red-Light Running Vehicle Warning System Based on Time-To-Collision Sensor

Vehicle collision warning system and algorithm at intersection under internet-connected vehicles environment

Investigating the effects of in-vehicle warning strategies to drivers: A driving simulator study