Abstract:OBJECTIVE: Previous research has found elevated injury risk for females relative to males in passenger vehicle crashes but has not accounted for ways the crashes themselves differ between these populations. Vehicle curb weight, ride height, safety rating, airbag deployment, and crash configuration all influence injury outcome and often are not well-represented by delta-V alone. This study evaluated the effect of occupant sex on injury risk in front and side crashes while limiting or controlling for non-physiological crash differences. Additionally, the effects of crashworthiness improvements are compared for females and males.METHODS: NASS-CDS cases from 1998-2015 calendar years involving a belted driver in a front crash or a struck-side driver or right front passenger in a side crash were analyzed. Case vehicle model years were 1989-2016. Logistic regression was used to estimate the risk of MAIS ≥ 2 and MAIS ≥ 3 injury outcomes for females relative to males as well as the change in risk due to improved crashworthiness. Sex-based differences in occupant age, mass, and stature; crash test rating; delta-V; crash configuration; and vehicle-to-vehicle compatibility were considered either through case selection or the inclusion of additional regression covariates.RESULTS: Before controlling for crash and vehicle differences, female drivers in front crashes had higher estimated overall and body-region-specific risks of MAIS ≥ 2 and MAIS ≥ 3 injury, as consistent with previous findings. After accounting for such differences, all ratios of injury odds for females relative to males were reduced. Females remained at higher risk of MAIS ≥ 2 injury (OR, 2.23; 95% CI, 1.42-3.51), especially extremity injury, but had similar odds for MAIS ≥ 3 non-extremity injury (OR, 0.98; 95% CI, 0.56-1.7). While controlling for crash differences in side impacts, none of the estimated injury risk differences by sex were significant at the <i>p</i> ≤ 0.05 level. Estimated benefits of improved crashworthiness were similar or greater for females than for males for most injury outcomes.CONCLUSIONS: Female-specific crashworthiness improvements may be required to provide additional protection against AIS 2 extremity injury. Much of the remaining discrepancy in sex-based injury risk can be attributed differences between vehicles and crashes, not to physiological differences. Addressing these differences will require other types of countermeasures.

Differences of Anthropometric Dimensions between Chinese and American and the Effects on Drivers’ Injury Risks in Vehicle Frontal Crash

Should anthropometric differences between the commonly used pedestrian computational biomechanics models and Chinese population be taken into account when predicting pedestrian head kinematics and injury in vehicle collisions in China?

Obesity and non-fatal motor vehicle crash injuries: sex difference effects

Translational medical bioengineering research of traumatic brain injury among Chinese and American pedestrians caused by vehicle collision based on human body finite element modeling

BMI and Risk of Serious Upper Body Injury Following Motor Vehicle Crashes: Concordance of Real-World and Computer-Simulated Observations

Regression Analysis of Lower Extremity Injury Influencing Factors under Frontal Crash

The Elderly and Motor Vehicle Crashes

FEM Simulation of Pedestrian-Vehicle Accidents Based on Parameters of Chinese Human Body

Research On Injury Criterions Prescribed In Automotive Frontal Crash Regulations

A numerical investigation of factors affecting lumbar spine injuries in frontal crashes

A Study of an Asian Anthropometric Pedestrian in Vehicle–pedestrian Accidents Using Real-World Accident Data

Injury risks and crashworthiness benefits for females and males: Which differences are physiological?

A computational study of injury severity and pattern sustained by overweight drivers in frontal motor vehicle crashes

Influence of Vehicle Model Year and Occupant Seating Position on Serious Injury Risk in Near-Side Collision

Contact Position Relation Between Car Bumpers and Lower Limbs of Pedestrians Involved in Crashes

A Computational Investigation on the Effect of Vehicle Rotation on Driver Injury Metrics in Frontal Offset Crash

Adaptive restraint design for a diverse population through machine learning

Effects of Anthropometric Variables and Seat Height on Automobile Drivers’ Preferred Posture With the Presence of the Clutch

The Combined Effects of Impact Direction and Impact Location on Serious-to-Maximum Injuries among Drivers in Motor Vehicle Frontal Crashes

Driver Injury Severity Analysis of Crashes in a Western China's Rural Mountainous County: Taking Crash Compatibility Difference into Consideration

Differences in Factors Affecting Various Crash Types with High Numbers of Fatalities and Injuries in China