Abstract:Objective: Several studies have documented the relative risk or odds of injury and fatality for females versus males in motor vehicle crashes (Parenteau et al. 2013, Forman et al. 2019, Brumbelow and Jermakian, 2022; Noh et al. 2022). Though, none combined National Automotive Sampling System-Crashworthiness Data System (NASS-CDS) and Crash Investigation Sampling System (CISS). The aim of this study was to document the relative odds of various injury outcomes for females versus males while considering a broad range of crash types, pre-crash and crash variables, and occupant characteristics. Methods: Multivariable logistic regression was carried out to study the odds of injury for females versus males. A select imputation method (Hot Deck, Approximate Bayesian Bootstrap) was applied as part of efforts to create multivariable logistic regression models for 25 different injury outcomes associated with occupants (age 13 years and older) involved in passenger vehicle crashes published in NASS-CDS (2000 to 2015) and CISS (2017-2021). Both pre-crash (n=7) and crashworthiness (n=22) predictor variables were considered, but only significant variables at p≤0.10 level were retained in final models. Six crash-type models were produced for each injury outcome; one that included all crashes, one for each of four different planar crash types (frontal, near-side, far-side, rear), and one for crashes involving rollover. These six sets of crash-type models were expanded further to include a model version that included both pre-crash/environment and crashworthiness predictor variables and one model limited to crashworthiness predictors only. Different than other recent studies, all crash types, occupant restraint conditions, and seating positions were considered. Occupant sex was retained in all models to facilitate female versus male injury outcome odds ratio (OR) assessments. Results: Female versus male injury OR estimates for 300 unique models are presented. Females had significantly higher odds of injury than males in 36 models (OR>1.0, p-value ≤0.05). This contrasts with 43 models where females had significantly lower odds (OR<1.0, p≤0.05). For the remaining 221 models, there was a near even split in how often the odds of injury were non-significantly higher (n=103) and non-significantly lower (n=114) for females as compared to males (p>0.05). In four cases, the OR estimate was 1.00. Amongst the results, there was a trend for females to have higher odds of AIS 2+ injuries (MAIS 2+ OR=1.75 and 1.69 for Full and Crashworthiness models, respectively for the All Crashes dataset). These increases included higher estimates for lower extremity injuries in frontal crashes, consistent with earlier studies (e.g., Forman et al. 2019). However, for certain AIS 2+ (neck, thorax) and AIS 3+ injuries (head, neck, thorax), females had significantly lower odds of injury (p≤0.05). The trends for reduced odds of injury for females were most prevalent in non-frontal crash models.

Obesity and non-fatal motor vehicle crash injuries: sex difference effects

BMI and Risk of Serious Upper Body Injury Following Motor Vehicle Crashes: Concordance of Real-World and Computer-Simulated Observations

Obesity and Risk for Death Due to Motor Vehicle Crashes.

A computational study of injury severity and pattern sustained by overweight drivers in frontal motor vehicle crashes

Injury risks and crashworthiness benefits for females and males: Which differences are physiological?

Sex-based differences in odds of motor vehicle crash injury outcomes

Effects of Obesity on Occupant Responses in Frontal Crashes: A Simulation Analysis Using Human Body Models

Body Mass Index Does Not Predict Injury Pattern or Outcome After Motorcycle Crash

Obesity Effects on Pedestrian Lower Extremity Injuries in Vehicle-to-pedestrian Impacts: A Numerical Investigation Using Human Body Models.

Impact of Obesity on All-Cause and Cause-Specific Mortality among Critically Ill Men and Women: a Cohort Study on the Eicu Database

The association between seatbelt use and trauma outcomes: Does body mass index matter?

Differences of Anthropometric Dimensions between Chinese and American and the Effects on Drivers’ Injury Risks in Vehicle Frontal Crash

A Simulation Study on the Efficacy of Advanced Belt Restraints to Mitigate the Effects of Obesity for Rear-Seat Occupant Protection in Frontal Crashes

Nationwide Analysis of Biomechanics of Motor Vehicle Collisions Involving Passenger Vehicle and Associated Outcomes: Towards Improving Vehicle Safety Standards and Regulations

Female vs. male relative fatality risk in fatal motor vehicle crashes in the US, 1975–2020

A Comprehensive Statewide Analysis of Seatbelt Non-Use with Injury and Hospital Admissions: New Data, Old Problem

The Association of Driver Age with Traffic Injury Severity in Wisconsin

Female crash fatality risk relative to males for similar physical impacts

Does gender make a difference? Seatbelt use and the risk of severe injuries among drivers hospitalized in Level-1 trauma centers

Body mass index influence on lap belt position and abdominal injury in frontal motor vehicle crashes

Obesity as a Risk Factor for Adverse Outcomes After Pedestrian Trauma Accidents in the Pediatric Population