A comparative study of interventional bronchoscopy in treatment of tuberculous scar central airway stenosis
Min Chen,Liyan Bo,Yan Wang,Xigang Yan,Lei Pan,Wangping Li,Faguang Jin,Deguang Mu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-436X.2017.08.006
2017-01-01
Abstract:Objective To explore the safety and effectiveness of the commonly used interventional bronchoscopy in the treatment of tuberculous scar central airway stenosis,and find out the best treatment method for this kind of patients.Methods 85 patients with tuberculous scar central airway stenosis were divided into four groups:group A was treated with balloon dilation alone,group B was treated with balloon dilation and freezing,group C was treated with balloon dilation and needle-shaped electric knife,group D was treated with balloon dilation and topical application of mitomycin for injection.Each patient was treated with interventional therapy once a week for four weeks,and the efficacy was evaluated at the 5th,9th,13rd,21st,25th,and 29th week.Evaluation indexes included dyspnea score,KPS,degree of stenosis,length of stenosis,efficiency,and clinical benefit rate.Results Compared with before treatment,the dyspnea score,KPS and the degree of stenosis were significantly improved in all patients after treatment,but there was no significant difference among groups.The efficiency in group B was lower (82.4％),the efficiency and clinical benefit rate in other three groups were more than 90％,and there was no significant difference among the four groups.Conclusions The above methods can be effective in the treatment of tuberculous scar stenosis,there is no statistical significance among the four groups.In order to simplify the treatment program and reduce the cost of treatment,we recommend the use of balloon dilation alone for the treatment of tuberculous scar central airway stenosis among the four methods mentioned above.