Research on Consumers′Subsequent Behavior Intentions under the Situation of Forced Positive Evaluation
Yan LI,Suping HUANG,Dongjin LI
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2017.05.002
2017-01-01
Journal of Management Science
Abstract:Firm stimulated word-of-mouth activity is defined as a firm′s proactive management of consumer-to-consumer communi-cation.With the rising development of social network, a growing number of firms urge consumers to post positive evaluation by material rewards as an exchange in order to realize word-of-mouth marketing.The methods of material rewards include gift, cash, price discount, and so on.Firm stimulated word-of-mouth are widely applied by many kinds of firms which are consumer-orien-ted.However, the word-of-mouth incentive mode by"post positive evaluation for material rewards as an exchange" is framed in an avoidance frame unavoidably.Sometimes, consumers have to post positive evaluation online in order to avoid loss. Most of the existing researches about forced word-of-mouth have focused on how material rewards promote consumers′word-of-mouth communication from the positive aspect, while this paper adds the negative aspect of the material rewards′influence on consumers′word-of-mouth to the existing literature.Based on the theory of psychological reactance and principle of cognitive con-sistency, this paper explores consumers′subsequent behavior intentions after forced positive word-of-mouth and its underlying mechanism.Two behavioral experiments have selected the part-time students and general consumers as samples separately. ANOVA, regression analysis and Bootstrap mediator analysis in SPSS are used to test hypotheses. It is found that reactance has negative impact on consumers′subsequent behavior intentions ( such as reducing recommenda-tion intention in future, increasing deleting intention of forced positive evaluation) .Perceived consistency of product′s actual ex-perience and word-of-mouth content has positive impact on subsequent behavior intentions.And this process is mediated by react-ance.In addition, compared to weakly reactants, highly reactants are inclined to have more negative subsequent behavior inten-tion.Consumers′trait reactance moderates the relationship between perceived consistency and subsequent behavior intention.As for highly reactants, the influence of perceived consistency on subsequent behavior intention is much weaker. The results of this paper provide theoretical guidance of firm stimulated word-of-mouth marketing to firms, and enrich the theory of word-of-mouth marketing and psychological reactance theory.The conclusions enlighten firms to frame this marketing tactic in"positive post, then gain" pattern rather than"no positive post, then loss" pattern.If the selling of products or services in a firm is heavily dependent on consumers′replicate purchase behavior, forced positive evaluation would have considerably neg-ative influence on consumers′overall satisfaction and restrain their subsequent purchase behavior to a great extent.For this rea-son, firms and retailers should realize the negative aspects of forced positive evaluation.Although positive actual experience of product or service may restrain consumers′negative behavioral responses effectively, this method cannot be effective towards all consumers, for example, for highly reactants.