Abstract:Prior research has consistently demonstrated that consumers have a negative preference for brands associated with dissociative groups. Conditions under which these preferences might be changed have remained largely unexamined. The current work investigates the effect of threat of freedom on consumers' preferences for brands associated with dissociative groups. We propose that consumers who experience a high level of threat of freedom will prefer brands associated with dissociative groups. This effect is mediated by a heightened feeling of psychological reactance induced by the high level of threat of freedom. We also examined the moderating role of narrative and self-esteem on the effect. One pilot experiment and three laboratory experiments were conducted to test our conceptualization. In experiment 1, we assessed the basic effect by which threat of freedom influences consumers' preferences for brands associated with dissociative groups. In this experiment, we also examined the mediating effect of psychological reactance. In experiment 2, we tested the robustness of the effect found in experiment 1 and investigated the moderating role of means of narrative through a two-by-two inter-subject design (freedom threat: low vs. high and means of narrative: yes vs. no). In experiment 3, we investigated the moderating role of self-esteem through a two-by-two mixed design (freedom threat: low vs. high and self-esteem: low vs. high). The results of three experiments confirm our predictions. The results of experiment 1 showed that the participants in the high threat-of-freedom group tended to prefer brands associated with dissociative groups. This effect was found to be mediated by psychological reactance. In experiment 2, our findings showed that the influence of threat of freedom on consumers' preference for brands associated with dissociative groups was replicated when a non-narrative information transmission model was used, and the effect was mitigated when a narrative information transmission mode was used. Finally, experiment 3 confirmed the moderating role of self-esteem by showing that participants with high self-esteem tended to prefer brands associated with dissociative groups when they experienced high vs. low threat of freedom. For participants with low self-esteem, such effects became non-significantly different. The current research has theoretical and practical contributions in the following aspects. First, it contributes to the literature of dissociative groups by documenting a condition in which consumers' negative attitude toward brands associated with dissociative groups can be improved. Second, this research extends the current literature on threat of freedom by revealing a preference for brands associated with dissociative groups as a new behavioral downstream. Finally, our findings have clear marketing implications. Certain types of consumers may experience varying levels of threat of freedom. Marketers may consider using actors who represent a dissociative identity in their marketing communications to attract this type of consumers.

To Conform or Deviate? the Effect of Resource Scarcity on Consumer Preference for Minority-Endorsed Options

Restrained by Resources: the Effect of Scarcity Cues and Childhood Socioeconomic Status (SES) on Consumer Preference for Feasibility

The Lonely Consumer: Loner or Conformer?

The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

Purchasing Luck: the Impact of Scarcity Cues on Superstitious Behavior

When Will Consumers Choose Brands Associated with Dissociative Groups?

Effect of Status Threat on Preference for Cross-Domain Self-Improvement Products: the Moderation of Trade-off Beliefs

Consequences of scarcity: the impact of perceived scarcity on executive functioning and its neural basis

Asserting Your Mind: Interruptions Extremize Consumer Choices

Can Scarcity of Products Promote or Restrain Consumers' Word-of-mouth in Social Networks? the Moderating Roles of Products' Social Visibility and Consumers' Self-Construal

A Cross-Cultural Study on the Effects of Social Popularity and Deal Scarcity on Consumers' Purchase Behavior.

How scarcity influences home country consumers' attitudes toward the firm engaging in cross-border philanthropy? The role of perceived distributive justice

Impact of Perceived Scarcity on Delay of Gratification: Meditation Effects of Self-Efficacy and Self-Control

Need for uniqueness moderates the effectiveness of different types of scarcity appeals

Influence of Scarcity on Word of Mouth Marketing Subject from the Perspective of Competition Awareness

The impact of social crowding on color saturation preference: The mediating role of threat to freedom and avoidance behavior

The Effect of Scarcity on Individuals' Psychology and Behavior:An Explanation from a More Integrated Perspective

Concern for the future and saving the earth: When does ecological resource scarcity promote pro-environmental behavior?

Resource scarcity aggravates ingroup bias: Neural mechanisms and cross‐scenario validation

A meta‐analysis on the effects of product scarcity

To Be or Not to Be Unique? The Effect of Social Exclusion on Consumer Choice