Trouble with Physics: Time to Follow Beauty?

Frank Wilczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0262-4079(13)60572-2

2013-01-01

Abstract:Aesthetics is the most reliable guide as we seek a more complete theory of matter beyond the standard model, argues Frank Wilczek

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Reasonable Ineffectiveness of Aesthetics in Particle Physics

Johannes Branahl

2024-06-22

Abstract:In recent years, criticism of the methodology of particle physics beyond the Standard Model has increased, diagnosing too much reliance on aesthetic criteria for theory development and evaluation. Faced with several decades of experimental confirmation of all theories lacking, we subject four aesthetic criteria - simplicity, symmetry, elegance, and inevitability -, regularly mentioned in theory evaluation, to critical examination. We find that these criteria, all of which can be reduced to a desire for simplicity, have repeatedly misled modern particle physics. This is largely due to the lack of metatheoretical permanence of a uniform conception of simplicity. The reductionist claim of particle physics - the search for simple fundamental principles in a complex world - will be worked out as the reason why this discipline is particularly susceptible to the aesthetic appeal of simplicity. Thus, compared to disciplines dealing with complex phenomena, aesthetic criteria are much more frequently applied, exposing particle physics to the risk of missteps and dead ends.

History and Philosophy of Physics
Particle Physics for Cosmology

Frank Wilczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9608285

1996-08-09

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

Abstract:I discuss some central issues in particle physics which are potentially relevant to cosmology. I first briefly review the present (glorious) experimental status of the Standard Model, emphasizing that it provides a firm foundation both for early Universe cosmology and for further exploration toward the basic laws of Nature. I then provide a critique, arguing that while there are no clear discrepancies, there are several major, specific deficiencies of the Standard Model which clearly point up its provisional character. I elaborate on the story theorists have made up to address one of these problems, the problem of scattered multiplets, and show how upon following it out one finds, within existing experiments, encouragement -- bordering on evidence -- for certain ambitious ideas regarding unification and supersymmetry. I briefly describe and contrast two paradigms of supersymmetry breaking, which have markedly different experimental and cosmological consequences. I call attention to specific connections with cosmology where appropriate throughout; and near the end I make some more global remarks. Finally I venture a speculation suggesting, in a fairly concrete way, the possibility that the laws of physics cannot, in principle, be disentangled from cosmology.
Beauty Physics in the Next 15 Years -- an Itinerary for a Long Journey towards an Essential Goal

I.I.Bigi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0168-9002%2894%2991087-1

1994-07-07

Abstract:After re-stating why beauty physics is so special and sketching its present status I attempt to map out an itinerary for the next fifteen years. The basic elements are listed for a research program that allows to define and probe the KM unitarity triangle in a manner where the numerical uncertainties are reduced to the few percent level. Dedicated experiments at the LHC will be essential in exploiting the discovery guarantee in beauty physics to the fullest. This paper is dedicated to Prof. H. Kastrup on the occasion of his 60th birthday. I have spent five years at his institute at the RWTH Aachen and I truly enjoyed the stimulating atmosphere he created by encouraging intellectual exchange unimpeded by hierarchical privileges.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Truth, Beauty and Supergravity

S. Deser

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4994807

2017-06-08

Abstract:I use Supergravity as a test case to study the role and uses of elegance/simplicity in formulating and evaluating physical models, whose sole criterion is of course truth: an observationally verified description of Nature within a certain range of scales.

History and Philosophy of Physics
From the Standard Model to Dark Matter

Frank Wilczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.48314

1995-01-20

Abstract:The standard model of particle physics is marvelously successful. However, it is obviously not a complete or final theory. I shall argue here that the structure of the standard model gives some quite concrete, compelling hints regarding what lies beyond. Taking these hints seriously, one is led to predict the existence of new types of very weakly interacting matter, stable on cosmological time scales and produced with cosmologically interesting densities--that is, ``dark matter''.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Mathematical Modeling of Physical Reality: From Numbers to Fractals, Quantum Mechanics and the Standard Model

Marian Kupczynski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e26110991

IF: 2.738

2024-11-27

Entropy

Abstract:In physics, we construct idealized mathematical models in order to explain various phenomena which we observe or create in our laboratories. In this article, I recall how sophisticated mathematical models evolved from the concept of a number created thousands of years ago, and I discuss some challenges and open questions in quantum foundations and in the Standard Model. We liberated nuclear energy, landed on the Moon and built 'quantum computers'. Encouraged by these successes, many believe that when we reconcile general relativity with quantum theory we will have the correct theory of everything. Perhaps we should be much humbler. Our perceptions of reality are biased by our senses and by our brain, bending them to meet our priors and expectations. Our abstract mathematical models describe only in an approximate way different layers of physical reality. To describe the motion of a meteorite, we can use a concept of a material point, but the point-like approximation breaks completely when the meteorite hits the Earth. Similarly, thermodynamic, chemical, molecular, atomic, nuclear and elementary particle layers of physical reality are described using specific abstract mathematical models and approximations. In my opinion, the theory of everything does not exist.

physics, multidisciplinary
Natural Philosophy versus Philosophy of Naturalness

Goran Senjanovic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0217732320300062

2020-01-30

Abstract:I reflect on some of the basic aspects of present day Beyond the Standard Model particle physics, focusing mostly on the issues of naturalness, in particular on the so-called hierarchy problem. To all of us, physics as natural science emerged with Galileo and Newton, and led to centuries of unparalleled success in explaining and often predicting new phenomena of nature. I argue here that the long standing obsession with the hierarchy problem as a guiding principle for the future of our field has had the tragic consequence of deviating high energy physics from its origins as natural philosophy, and turning it into a philosophy of naturalness.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,High Energy Physics - Experiment,High Energy Physics - Theory,History and Philosophy of Physics
Physics in 100 Years

Frank Wilczek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/PT.3.3137

2015-03-26

Abstract:Here I indulge in wide-ranging speculations on the shape of physics, and technology closely related to physics, over the next one hundred years. Themes include the many faces of unification, the re-imagining of quantum theory, and new forms of engineering on small, intermediate, and large scales.

Popular Physics
Lost in Math? A review of 'Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray', by Sabine Hossenfelder

Jeremy Butterfield

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1902.03480

2019-02-10

Abstract:This is a review of Hossenfelder's book, 'Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray'. The book gives a breezy exposition of the present situation in fundamental physics, and raises important questions: both about the content of the physics, and the way physics research is organized. I first state my main disagreements. Then, I mostly praise the book: I concentrate on Hossenfelder's discussion of supersymmetry, naturalness and the multiverse.

History and Philosophy of Physics
Fundamental Dilemmas in Theoretical Physics

Hisham Ghassib

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1405.5530

2014-05-22

History and Philosophy of Physics

Abstract:In this paper, we argue that there are foundational dilemmas in theoretical physics related to the concept of reality and the nature of mathematics in physics. Physical theory is treated as a conceptual organism which develops under the weight of its internal contradictions. The paper discusses in depth the problem of objective reality in physics and its relation to scientific practice. Then, it explores the problematic relation between physical meaning and mathematics in modern physical theory, followed by a discussion of the trend of contemporary physics to replace physical principles with pure mathematical principles. Finally, it discusses the problem of logical coherence in modern physical theory. The paper emphasizes the importance of resolving these dilemmas to the proper practice of theoretical physics.
A New Insight on Physical Phenomenology: a Review

Stefano Bellucci,Fabio Cardone,Fabio Pistella

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/sym13040607

2023-08-13

Abstract:After a brief digression on the current landscape of theoretical physics and on some open questions pertaining to coherence with experimental results, still to be settled, it is shown that the properties of the Deformed Minkowski space lead to a plurality of potential physical phenomena that should occur, provided that the resulting formalisms can be considered as useful models for the descrip-tion of some aspects of physical reality. A list is given of available experimental evidences not easy to be interpreted, at present, by means of the more established models, such as the standard model with its variants aimed at overcoming its descriptive limits; these evidences could be candidates to verify the predictions stemming from the properties of the Deformed Minkowski space. The list includes: anomalies in the double-slit-like experiments; nuclear metamorphosis; torsional anten-nas, as well as the physical effect of the "geometric vacuum" (as defined in analogy with quantum vacuum), in the absence of external electromagnetic field, when crossing critical thresholds of energy parameter values, energy density in space and energy density in time.

General Physics
Unification and Emergence in Physics: the Problem of Articulation

Ian T. Durham

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1001.4304

2010-01-25

Abstract:What is physics? What are the limits of what physics can say about the world? In seeking ever-broader theoretical `umbrellas' for physical phenomena, we are seeking unifying principles. Emergent phenomena have turned out to be some of the most difficult to explain, causing a `clash of umbrellas' so-to-speak, at the interface between the quantum and classical domains. This essay explores the role of articulation in this particularly vexing problem and ultimately addresses the question of whether the language and mathematics we use to describe the universe is sufficient in its present form and application.

History and Philosophy of Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
Beauty and physics — Physics projects based on modern aesthetic and medical treatments

Anett Nagy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1929/1/012027

2021-05-01

Journal of Physics: Conference Series

Abstract:Abstract As a natural science, physics seeks to answer questions that arise in the world around us. One of the areas of motivation is to show students that a number of devices and treatments used in the beauty industry or for staying healthy apply the laws and phenomena of physics. Examining the physical background of various, modern treatments can be used to raise simple and complicated issues in physics and also provides us the opportunity to carry out qualitative or quantitative experiments. We believe that these projects assist students in a better understanding of physics and also encourage teachers to make the subject more interesting.

English Else
Aesthetic Motivation in Quantum Physics: Past and Present

Henrik Zinkernagel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/andp.202200283

2023-03-16

Abstract:This essay explores the relations between aesthetics and motivation, primarily in quantum physics, focusing on the notions of play, beauty, and the joy of insight. The motivating role of these notions is examined both historically among the quantum pioneers and contemporarily, based on a series of interviews, among physicists associated with the Niels Bohr Institute in Copenhagen.

History and Philosophy of Physics,Quantum Physics
"The important thing is not to stop questioning", including the symmetries on which is based the Standard Model

Daniel Sternheimer

2023-04-16

Abstract:New fundamental physical theories can, so far a posteriori, be seen as emerging from existing ones via some kind of deformation. That is the basis for Flato's ``deformation philosophy", of which the main paradigms are the physics revolutions from the beginning of the twentieth century, quantum mechanics (via deformation quantization) and special relativity. On the basis of these facts we describe two main directions by which symmetries of hadrons (strongly interacting elementary particles) may ``emerge" by deforming in some sense (including quantization) the Anti de Sitter symmetry (AdS), itself a deformation of the Poincare group of special relativity. The ultimate goal is to base on fundamental principles the dynamics of strong interactions, which originated half a century ago from empirically guessed ``internal" symmetries. After a rapid presentation of the physical (hadrons) and mathematical (deformation theory) contexts, we review a possible explanation of photons as composites of AdS singletons (in a way compatible with QED) and of leptons as similar composites (massified by 5 Higgs, extending the electroweak model to 3 generations). Then we present a ``model generating" multifaceted framework in which AdS would be deformed and quantized (possibly at root of unity and/or in manner not yet mathematically developed with noncommutative ``parameters"). That would give (using deformations) a space-time origin to the ``internal" symmetries of elementary particles, on which their dynamics were based, and either question, or give a conceptually solid base to, the Standard Model, in line with Einstein's quotation:``The important thing is not to stop questioning. Curiosity has its own reason for existing."

High Energy Physics - Theory,Mathematical Physics,Quantum Algebra
Physics is Organized Around Transformations Connecting Contextures in a Polycontextural World

Johannes Falk,Edwin Eichler,Katja Windt,Marc-Thorsten Hütt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-021-09814-0

2021-08-10

Foundations of Science

Abstract:Abstract The rich body of physical theories defines the foundation of our understanding of the world. Its mathematical formulation is based on classical Aristotelian (binary) logic. In the philosophy of science the ambiguities, paradoxes, and the possibility of subjective interpretations of facts have challenged binary logic, leading, among other developments, to Gotthard Günther’s theory of polycontexturality (often also termed ’transclassical logic’). Günther’s theory explains how observers with subjective perception can become aware of their own subjectivity and provides means to describe contradicting or even paradox observations in a logically sound formalism. Here we summarize the formalism behind Günther’s theory and apply it to two well-known examples from physics where different observers operate in distinct and only locally valid logical systems. Using polycontextural logic we show how the emerging awareness of these limitations of logical systems entails the design of mathematical transformations, which then become an integral part of the theory. In our view, this approach offers a novel perspective on the structure of physical theories and, at the same time, emphasizes the relevance of the theory of polycontexturality in modern sciences.

history & philosophy of science
Fundamental Themes in Physics from the History of Art

Robert Fleck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00016-020-00269-7

2020-11-27

Physics in Perspective

Abstract:Mindful of a stated <i>Project 2061</i> goal of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, emphasizing that "scientific literacy includes seeing the scientific endeavor in the light of cultural and intellectual history," and in the continuing spirit of narrowing the gap between the "two cultures" by enhancing STEAM awareness and education, this essay illustrates, quite literally through well-known works of Western art, the striking parallels between fundamental themes in physics and the visual arts through history. These connections include: the identification of microcosm–macrocosm analogies in prehistoric proto-science; the beginning of the appreciation in pre-classical antiquity of the lawfulness of nature under the aegis of a Divine Lawgiver; the rise of rationalism and the first theories of the architecture of matter during the so-called "Greek miracle"; the overlapping role of theology's "handmaiden" during the emblematic medieval Age of Faith; Renaissance renovations and the triumph of the "mechanical universe" as the capstone of the scientific revolution in the early modern period; the influence on physics of the Romantic notion of an underlying unity in all of nature, and the increasing abstraction in both art and physics during the nineteenth century; and, finally, the parallels between twentieth-century art and the physics of relativity and quantum theory, concluding with examples from modern cosmology.

history & philosophy of science
Free Will in the Theory of Everything

Fabio Scardigli,Gerard ’t Hooft,Emanuele Severino,Piero Coda

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-05505-9_2

2019-01-01

Abstract:From what is known today about the elementary particles of matter and the forces that control their behaviour, it may be observed that a host of obstacles to our further understanding remain to be overcome. Most researchers conclude that drastically new concepts must be investigated, new starting points are needed, older structures and theories, in spite of their successes, will have to be overthrown, and new, superintelligent questions will have to be asked and investigated. In short, they say that we shall need new physics. Here, we argue in a different manner. Today, no prototype, or toy model, of any so-called theory of everything exists, because the demands required of such a theory appear to be conflicting. The demands that we propose include locality, special and general relativity, together with a fundamental finiteness not only of the forces and amplitudes, but also of nature’s set of dynamical variables. We claim that the two ingredients we have today, quantum field theory and general relativity, do indeed go a long way towards satisfying such elementary requirements. Putting everything together in a grand synthesis is like solving a gigantic puzzle. We argue that we need the correct analytical tools to solve this puzzle. Finally, it seems obvious that this solution will leave room neither for `divine intervention’, nor for `free will’, an observation that, all by itself, can be used as a clue. We claim that this reflects on our understanding of the deeper logic underlying quantum mechanics.
Comment on Frank Wilczek's essay "Total Relativity: Mach 2004"

G. E. Hahne

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0512204

2006-01-08

Abstract:Frank Wilczek's essay "Total Relativity: Mach 2004" (PHYSICS TODAY April, 2004, p. 10) cogently updates the status of the intuitively compelling, but partly unrealized, theory of Mach's Principle. I think, however, that an important consequence of the Principle has been skipped: that is, the possibility of linear deformations of the internal structure of elementary particles from the Minkowski structure imposed by the local gravitational (metric) field. [Note: This Comment is similar to one submitted to, but not published by, PHYSICS TODAY as a Letter to the Editor.]

Classical Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,History and Philosophy of Physics

Trouble with Physics: Time to Follow Beauty?

The Reasonable Ineffectiveness of Aesthetics in Particle Physics

Particle Physics for Cosmology

Beauty Physics in the Next 15 Years -- an Itinerary for a Long Journey towards an Essential Goal

Truth, Beauty and Supergravity

From the Standard Model to Dark Matter

Mathematical Modeling of Physical Reality: From Numbers to Fractals, Quantum Mechanics and the Standard Model

Natural Philosophy versus Philosophy of Naturalness

Physics in 100 Years

Lost in Math? A review of 'Lost in Math: How Beauty Leads Physics Astray', by Sabine Hossenfelder

Fundamental Dilemmas in Theoretical Physics

A New Insight on Physical Phenomenology: a Review

Unification and Emergence in Physics: the Problem of Articulation

Beauty and physics — Physics projects based on modern aesthetic and medical treatments

Aesthetic Motivation in Quantum Physics: Past and Present

"The important thing is not to stop questioning", including the symmetries on which is based the Standard Model

Physics is Organized Around Transformations Connecting Contextures in a Polycontextural World

Fundamental Themes in Physics from the History of Art

Free Will in the Theory of Everything

Comment on Frank Wilczek's essay "Total Relativity: Mach 2004"