Abstract:XPS analyses of open shell ionic compounds, especially oxides of the first row transition metals, for information such as oxidation state tend to focus on characteristics of the metal 2p XPS features alone. These analyses could be made considerably more robust with simultaneous characterization of the XPS of the metal 3p features as well as the 2p features. In these comments, we provide a perspective on the conceptual and theoretical framework needed to extract chemical information from the complex multiplet structure of the 3p XPS of Fe oxides as representative of 3d transition metal oxides. We also present information about a novel kind of many-body effects that may contribute to a further redistribution of the Fe 3p XPS intensity. The concern here is not to develop a complicated mathematical formalism but to explain the complexity in terms of fundamental quantum mechanical concepts. This is done on the basis of ab initio Dirac Hartree–Fock wavefunctions where we examine the physical nature of the 3p XPS features of the representative ferrous and ferric oxides of FeO and Fe2O3, respectively. The key objectives of this paper are as follows: (1) to demonstrate the importance of the angular momentum coupling of open shell electrons, which is done more easily with RS multiplets; (2) to show that a single configuration description of the final state multiplets is woefully inadequate; (3) to identify a novel atomic many-body effect that can lead to a rich satellite structure. The considerations discussed here should have implications for making useful interpretations of the XPS of lower BE levels of other ionic, high spin materials. This paper provides a manifestation of a new tradition by which Comments on Inorganic Chemistry starts publishing original research content that, nonetheless, preserves the Journal's identity as a niche for critical discussion of contemporary literature in inorganic chemistry; for previous manifestations, see Comments Inorg. Chem. 2020, 40, 277–303 and references cited in the abstract thereof.

Cover Feature: Understanding the Uniqueness of 2p Elements in Periodic Tables (chem. Eur. J. 67/2020)

Understanding the Uniqueness of 2p Elements in Periodic Tables

Anisotropic Spectroscopy and Electrical Properties of 2D ReS2(1–x)Se2x Alloys with Distorted 1T Structure

Isomer triplets in odd-odd transitional rare earth nuclei: unique features, orbital systematics and characterization

Quantum octets in high mobility pentagonal two-dimensional PdSe 2

Hybridization and Correlation Between F- and D-Orbital Electrons in a Valence Fluctuating Compound EuNi2P2

σ-Aromaticity Planar Pentacoordinate Beryllium Atoms

Energetics and Electronic Structure of Plutonium

On the Quantum Chemical Nature of Lead(II) "Lone Pair"

Quantum Octets in Air Stable High Mobility Two-Dimensional PdSe2

Cover Feature: Tuning Energetics of 2 e−/2H+ PCET Properties with Model Ru‐bisamido Complexes (Chem. Eur. J. 54/2024)

Description of Noncovalent Interactions Involving Π-System with High Precision: an Assessment of RPA, MP2, and DFT-D Methods.

New Insights into the Nuclear Structure in Neutron-Rich 112,114,115,116,117,118Pd

Rejection of Rutherford's Planetary Model of the Atom, Bohr's Postulates and the Tunnel Effect

An Anomalous Electron Configuration Among 3d Transition Metal Atoms

Evolution of Low-Dimensional Phosphorus Allotropes on Ag(111)

Empirical Example Of Possible E(5) Symmetry Nucleus Pd-108

The importance of tight $f$ basis functions for heavy p-block oxides and halides: a parallel with tight $d$ functions in the second row

Super Heavy Elements: On the 150th Anniversary of the Discovery of the Periodic Table of Elements

Strong-correlated Behavior of 4f Electrons and 4f5d Hybridization in PrO2.

Comments on the Theory of Complex XPS Spectra: Extracting Chemical Information from the Fe 3p XPS of Fe Oxides