Aridity-driven Decoupling of Δ13c Between Pedogenic Carbonate and Soil Organic Matter

Jiawei Da,Yi Ge Zhang,Gen Li,Junfeng Ji

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1130/g47241.1

IF: 5.8

2020-01-01

Geology

Abstract:Pedogenic carbonate is an invaluable archive for reconstructing continental paleoclimate and paleoecology. The delta C-13 of pedogenic carbonate (delta C-13(c)) has been widely used to document the rise and expansion of C-4 plants over the Cenozoic. This application requires a fundamental presumption that in soil pores, soil-respired CO2 dominates over atmospheric CO2 during the formation of pedogenic carbonates. However, the decoupling between delta C-13, and delta C-13 of soil organic matter (delta C-13(SOM)) have been observed, particularly in arid regions, suggesting that this presumption is not always valid. To evaluate the influence of atmospheric CO2 on soil delta C-13(c), here we performed systematic delta C-13 analyses of paleosols across the Chinese Loess Plateau, with the sample ages spanning three intervals: the Holocene, the Late Pleistocene, and the mid-Pliocene warm period. Our paired delta C-13(c), and delta C-13(SOM) data reveal broadly divergent trending patterns. Using a two-component Ca-mixing model, we show substantial incorporations of atmospheric CO2 (up to 60%) into soil pore space during carbonate precipitation. This result readily explains the enrichment of delta C-13(c) and its divergence from delta C-13(SOM). As a consequence, delta C-13 of pedogenic carbonates formed under semiarid and/or arid conditions are largely driven by regional aridity through its control on soil CO2 composition, and thus cannot be used to evaluate the relative abundance of C-3 versus C-4 plants. Nonetheless, these carbonates can be applied for atmospheric CO2 reconstructions, even for periods with low CO2 levels.