Optimal design and effective control of Kaibel column with liquid-only transfer streams for quaternary distillation

Baiwen Kong,Qingjun Zhang,Chengtian Cui,Jinsheng Sun
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seppur.2020.117261
IF: 8.6
2020-01-01
Separation and Purification Technology
Abstract:The Kaibel column (KC) is considered to be energy effective and capital economical replacement of conventional distillation sequences for quaternary distillation. However, the industrialization of such a structure is still hesitant due to increased complexity and related uncertainties. Compared to the highly integrated KC, distillation configurations with liquid-only transfer streams (LTS) are more easily understandable and acceptable to the industrial community. A KC-LTS configuration is therefore investigated through an optimal design and controllability comparison to the conventional direct sequence (DS). When separation of aromatics is proposed as a case study, the results demonstrate the economic superiority of KC-LTS to DS in terms of the total annual cost. Considering the controllability using composition controllers, the former structure performs as favorable as the latter when tackling a +/- 20% step changes in throughput and feed composition. An inferential temperature control strategy is also established for KC-LTS. Good controllability is generally realized in most cases at handling relatively small (10%) throughput and feed composition disturbances, except for large product offsets when resisting large (20%) feed perturbations. To further improve its dynamic control effectiveness, an intensified control option with three composition control loops is successfully proposed to handle 20% step feed disturbances. Overall, this work expands LTS to quaternary distillation, suggesting a competitive substitute of the well-known KC for both academic and industrial purposes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?