Comparison of the Impact of Team-based Learning and Lecture-based Learning on Nursing Students' Core Competencies: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Xin Gao,Di Yan,Ya Zhang,Xiang Ruan,Tingyu Kang,Ruotong Wang,Qi Zheng,Siju Chen,Jinxia Zhai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nepr.2024.103945
IF: 3.43
2024-03-21
Nurse Education in Practice
Abstract:Aim This study aims to evaluate the effect of team-based learning on the core competence of nursing students compared with traditional teaching methods. Background In recent years, team-based learning has been widely used as a learning and teaching method in the world. Not only the necessary knowledge, skills and attitudes, but also the core competence is necessary to cope with various clinical situations for nursing students. However, the effect of this new teaching method on core competence of nursing students is not consistent. Design The study was designed according to the preferred reporting entries guidelines statement for systematic reviews and meta-analyses and population, intervention, comparison, outcome and study. Methods Data were collected from PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Science Direct and Scopus. The quality of studies was assessed using "The Newcastle Ottawa scale". A random-effect model of meta-analyses was conducted to generate pooled standardized mean differences (SMD) for core competence using Rev Man 5.4.1 software and STATASE 15. Moreover, subgroup, heterogeneity, sensitivity and publication bias analyses were conducted. Results A total of 14 articles with 1,942 participants were included in the meta-analysis. Compared with the traditional pedagogy among nursing students, team-based learning pedagogy significantly increased theoretical performance, professional effects (self-directed learning ability and communication ability) but did not affect practice skills. In addition, one study found that learning attitudes were not improved in students with high or low academic performance. This might mean that the teaching model should be implemented for a long time, which essentially changed students' learning attitudes to improve students' self-directed learning ability and core competence, especially for students with low scores. Conclusions In summary, findings indicated that team-based learning pedagogical approaches might be beneficial to improve teaching quality in nursing education. However, practice skills might not be sensitive to team-based learning because of the seriation of the original course. Nursing educators need to explore teaching strategies to cultivate high-quality nursing talents to cultivate nursing students with core competence and ensure that they are successfully qualified for new employment.
nursing