Meta analysis of telephone follow-up on the application effect of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease patients

Jing Jin,Caiyun Zhang,Zhigang Zhang,Jinhui Tian,Fang Su,Juanhong Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/cma.j.issn.1673-4351.2018.03.006
2018-01-01
International Journal of Nursing
Abstract:Objective To evaluate the application effect of telephone follow-up on chronic obstructive pulmo-nary disease patients. Methods Computer was used to retrieve the database of Wanfang Data, CNKI, CBM, PubMed, The Cochrane library (stage 1, 2016) and Web of science. The time limit of retrieval was from library estab-lishment to June 6 , 2016 . The randomized controlled trials related to the application of telephone follow-up on COPD patients was were collected. After 2 evaluators were independently in charge of screening literatures, extracting infor-mation and evaluating the bias risk adopted to study, RevMan 5. 3 software was used to have Meta analysis. Results 11 RCT experiments and 914 patients were adopted. Compared with the conventional discharge guidance, Meta analysis result showed that the difference of telephone follow-up had statistical significance on smoking-quitting rate 〔OR=4. 16 , 95% CI (2. 78, 6. 23), P<0. 01〕, dependency (6-month and 12-month telephone follow-up, P<0. 01), the related knowledge awareness rate and FEV1 〔MD=0. 14, 95%CI (0. 12, 0. 17), P<0. 01〕 (P<0. 05). However, for the living quality 〔MD=-8. 24 , 95% CI (-20. 27 , 3. 80 ) , P=0. 18〕 and self-efficacy 〔MD=-0. 16 , 95% CI (-0. 54 , 0. 23 ) , P=0. 43〕, the difference had no statistical significance ( P>0. 05 ) . Conclusions The existing evi-dence shows that the application of telephone follow-up is effective to COPD patients. Due to the restrictions of study quantity and quality, the conclusion above still needs further high-quality RCT for demonstration.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?